1446 Comments
User's avatar
Len Kinder's avatar

VIRUSES EXIST.

_Computer code gets computer viruses (whether accidentally or intentionally) and it makes sense that genetic code should be prone to getting biological viruses in a similar way.

_I got into studying natural health in 1977 via Natural Hygiene, which was promoted mostly by Dr. Herbert M. Shelton and later by Dr. Virginia Vetrano and T.C. Fry. I continued to follow Natural Hygiene until 1996, when my health deteriorated on a vegan diet, which they promoted. T.C. Fry had argued that virus theory is absurd because he compared it to a flea on an elephant taking over the elephant to duplicate a mountain of more fleas out of the elephant's body. I never completely bought that position, but it seemed plausible.

CHANGED MIND.

_Starting in 1997 I red books by Dr. Leonard Horowitz about AIDS, Ebola, CJD, prions etc and I gathered that viruses are real.

_On Bitchute.com just a couple months ago I saw a short video interview of Dr. Tom Cowan in which he discussed Dr. Harold Hillman's findings that microbiology is erroneous because stains, centrifugation, electron microscopy etc produce artificial formations in cells and tissues that are not natural parts of living tissues. Viruses are imaged with electron microscopes, but they heat specimens with bombardment of electrons, which fries them, so they are bound to be greatly distorted, maybe comparable to the difference between a live human body and a corpse that's been around for a while.

_I made a post on this matter, called Is Microbiology Sound, at https://ilki.substack.com/p/is-microbiology-real . It includes links to some of Dr. Hillman's videos and his papers and to an MIT news article from 2009 about the damaging effects of electron microscopy.

_Dr. Cowan used Dr. Hillman's findings to support his view that viruses are not real, but I continue to think viruses are real for the reason I stated at the beginning as well as because of the great amount of info that seems to be known about viruses & diseases. I think viruses are generally only dangerous when our nutrition is lacking or our genome is damaged. However, it seems plausible that viruses could evolve or be weaponized to become severely parasitic or predatory, killing their hosts. There seems to be good evidence that AIDS viruses, Ebola etc are weaponized and Covid seems to be a less severe weaponized virus.

_One of the smartest people I know of, James Sloane, says cancer is caused mostly by viruses. He also says ozone therapy from a cold corona ozone generator is the best treatment for most cancers, but he also says the herb chaparral is very good for cancer. Also, Pau d'Arco etc. Dr. Eric Berg in some Youtube videos says cancer is usually caused by damage to mitochondria. So there's lots of food for thought.

Boostershots's avatar

Attention Scientists!

I've not received any answers for this question I posted on Igor's last article.

hCG is the hormone that women begin to produce in large quantities after becoming pregnant. This is the particle that pregnancy tests detect.

So which particle is bigger? The hCG hormone? Or COVID19 Virus?

(Hint: It’s a 50 to 1 size ratio, and the COVID particle is the fat one.)

We can isolate, purify, and then re-inject hCG in repeatable experiments to satisfy Koch’s postulates.

I've provided evidence with links in this article about the hCG isolation process.

https://boostershots.substack.com/p/the-no-virus-challenge-vs-the-no-83f

Are there any scientists out there on Igor’s blog who do hCG isolation for a living?

Or can anyone else refute the evidence I’ve provided about the isolation and purification of hCG from my previous article?

Where am I going wrong?

Why can’t we do this with a virus when it's 50 times bigger?

David Lamb's avatar

Well, Lanka has been trying for almost 30 years to get other scientists to answer the glaring questions, and he's still not received one sincere reply. The inescapable conclusion is that the corruption has progressed to such a degree that there's virtually no genuine scientists. Everyone in academia, corporate medicine, and government are paid not to be scientists, but to say and produce what benefits their employers. This outcome was sealed when we allowed the Rockefeller cabal to completely take over and monopolize medicine.

John's avatar

"This outcome was sealed when we allowed the Rockefeller cabal to completely take over and monopolize medicine."

The Rockefellar cabal do not practice medicine. The choice to call something medicine which is not medicine is something you are doing and have power to change. Medicine is not monopolized but open to all. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2ndU6EtokQ

https://onegreatworknetwork.com/patricia-lager/ogwn-live-stream-35-is-allopathy-the-1-cause-of-dis-ease

Boostershots's avatar

VIRUSES DO NOT EXIST

Just for the formality.

Len Kinder's avatar

_Boost., I'm not an expert. Are you? I'm interested in the answer to your question, but I don't know of any experts who may be willing to give the answer, if they know it. I think so-called "germ" theory and virus theory are likely correct in general. I don't think "germs" are the main cause of disease. I think malnourishment is the main cause. Another cause for some people is genetic defects.

_We all believe in parasites and predators, don't we? Predators can attack us, kill us and even eat us if they're interested. Parasites can invade our bodies in various ways and can cause disease or even fatality. I guess you'd agree that parasites can cause dysentery. I see no reason to think that some bacteria can't be parasites. Like H. pylori in the stomach, causing ulcers. Bacteria cause tooth decay and they can invade the circulatory system and end up about anywhere in the body, as well as the lungs, causing inflammation etc. Fungus can surely be parasitical as well. Toenail fungus. Candida can get into genitals and into the intestines. Most bacteria are friendly and harmless. Those in the intestines are vital to our survival. Some in the colon can be deadly if they get into our digestive systems.

_Virus can be defined as DNA or RNA fragments. By that definition, nearly everyone would agree that they exist, since cells often get damaged and the cell contents, including genetic material, can obviously get damaged in the process. But the question would be, can these fragments cause disease. Can the fragments be toxic? Anything can be toxic if it's in too great a quantity in cells or tissues. It can cause the death of cells and can even cause an entire organ to weaken or die. Can these viruses as genetic fragments cause disease by replicating? I think that's a more important question. I think the answer is yes, because genetic code is known to replicate, so it seems likely that some genetic fragments, i.e. viruses, should be capable of replicating under certain conditions. That's what I'm trying to get detailed answers to at https://ilki.substack.com/p/vax-questions-for-experts and https://ilki.substack.com/p/is-microbiology-real

I red' recently that the air everywhere even up to mountain tops contains thousands of viruses as proven in an experiment. The large majority of viruses are harmless, because they don't have the right genetic code to replicate, I think. So this is an example of my thinking that leads me to expect that viruses are real and can cause disease either by being toxic like any other toxin, or by replicating within susceptible cells, if they contain the right genetic code. Such viruses contain at least 20 thousand base "pairs" (nucleotides), so that may be enough for replication, I suppose. Some viruses may well not exist, like the rabies virus, according to Dr. Sam Bailey's video, which someone linked to earlier.

Boostershots's avatar

Len, I'm thrilled you're not an "expert". Because the "experts'" track record has been pretty abysmal for the last 2 years! We're all "experts" at this point as far as I'm concerned. Logic, data, repeatable experiments, open debate, and the pursuit of truth are the only things I value. Thanks for taking the time to respond.

But to answer your question directly, I'm not a virologist, scientist, or doctor. Boostershots is an eclectic group of anonymous free thinking individuals who are "experts" in undisclosed fields of study.

"We all believe in parasites and predators, don't we?"

Yes

"Predators can attack us, kill us and even eat us if they're interested."

Yes, but as far as "predators" go for us humans this is very rare, it happens in isolated incidents when the "predator" is starving, malnourished, or confused. And this doesn't include being "threatened", (like if you get too close to mama bear's cubs). We don't have the same worries that a mouse does.

"Parasites can invade our bodies in various ways and can cause disease or even fatality."

This is where we start to begin to have conflicting understandings. I do not think of parasites as little "mini predators". Here's an analogy that makes sense to me with regards to "parasites":

There are always roaches in all large apartment complexes. Roaches are always present, waiting for an opportunity, but they're not stalking you or "attacking" you like a "predator" would. They will not "invade" you apartment unless they can "take advantage" of the opportunity. You have to "invite them." If you have lots of cracks in your floors and walls, unsealed pipes, and most importantly, if you leave food/garbage out everywhere, then roaches will just waltz on in, (to your body)! These "parasites" are NEVER any match for a HEALTHY body, (a well kept apartment).

Even if your x2 adjacent neighbors live in filth with tons of roaches infesting every corner of THEIR apartments, those roaches won't ever "take over" YOUR body, (apartment), because YOU are healthy, (you seal all your wall cracks, you have sealed pipes, you never leave food out, and you clean your floors often). Your communal hallways have roaches, (not as bad as your nasty neighbors), but still not great. But YOUR Apartment is fine. At worse, you'll have a straggler roach run across your living room, but "your body" will swiftly go into action, and will take care of the roach with a newspaper, (hopefully not RAID or some other harmful chemical that your "body" doesn't like!) To put it simply, there's no way in hell that your neighbors "roaches" could ever "take down" your healthy apartment.

A group of boyscouts had an active day playing outside in the woods. Some of the boys even had a few major cuts and scrapes! Then all the boys jump in the lake to cool off. The lake is filled with quadrillions of dead things and bacteria and parasites and brain eating paramecia. But all the boys are happy, healthy, active, splashing water into each others faces, wrestling, ingesting huge gulps of lake water while doing so? But how? Why? How are the boys not all dead?! Open wounds in a lake of parasites?! How is this possible?

Because the boys are all very healthy. None of them are vitamin deficient. Just like for the roaches/apartment analogy, all the "roaches" of the "lake" were no match for the healthy boys, even with cuts and scraps. Vitamins are analogous the the apartments drywall, pipe sealant, vacuum cleaner, etc. In addition to "leaving food all over your apartment floor", i.e. (polluting your body with toxic food and chemicals), if your apartment, (body), is lacking things like caulk sealant, a vaccuum cleaner, trash bags, etc, it's hard to keep your apartment clean. Lacking Vitamin C, you get scurvey. Lacking pipe sealent? You get leaky rusty pipes".

 "Bacteria cause tooth decay and they can invade the circulatory system"

It's not the bacteria that's "attacking" your tooth or your blood. The bacteria is not even "parasitic", it's a level below, it is a true scavenger. It only consumes byproducts/wsateproducts you ate, and sometimes it is taking a toxic crap on you tooth because you polluted your body with bad sugary food that the bacteria eats as well.

In summary: Parsites, bacteria, fungus are all real, but NONE of them are "pathenogenic" like a "predatory" and certainly not "contagious" Viruses are completely made up fake unicorns to begin with.

"Virus can be defined as DNA or RNA fragments."

Naw dawg! What if you reversed it. Now think about this.

"DNA or RNA fragments can be defined as Viruses".

Really? We've got billions of cells dying inside of us all the time. It's totally normal. Or Body's are littered with dead cell debris, (including trillions of left over broken strands of DNA and RNA fragments from dead cells). Bacteria love to eat these organic pieces of baby food up. All bacteria are scavengers. Not a single species will ever "attack" you. Like a vulture, they will wait until you are dead before they start to eat you.

Leaky gut syndrome is another misunderstood and downright censored thing. We've got tons of bacteria in our gut which help us. But if they enter the bloodstream then they can cause problems. This only happens when the gut walls are damaged enough to allow the bacteria to leak into the blood.

"Can the fragments be toxic? Anything can be toxic if it's in too great a quantity in cells or tissues."

Natural dead cell debris is not "toxic". What can be toxic is the waste product of a small percentage of bacteria when they are forced to exists in a toxic environment. Like tetanus. Our bodies our littered with teens. It's fine...unless it's in an anaerobic condition, and then it mutates to rod form and THEN it "takes a toxic crap in you" which causes the serverve symptoms.

"Can these viruses as genetic fragments cause disease by replicating?"

Genetic fragments are waste products. They can't replaicte any more than a dead body can "replicate". Like frankenstein. It's fiction.

"Some viruses may well not exist, like the rabies virus, according to Dr. Sam Bailey's video, which someone linked to earlier."

Rabbies is a great rabbit hole to explore. Rabbles is nothing more than vitamin deficiency in dogs during the winter time. If dog's don't get the vitamins necessary to stay healthy and fend off the parasites that they normally can fend off, (or if the pipes in the apartment don't have sealent and are leaking and rusty), then that's why the dog appears to be "mad", when in fact the animal is just being agitated by the parasites and constantly nipping and salavatiing.

The "rabbid" dog lamented, If only there was some grass to eat under all this snow then I'd have my vitamins and be healthy!"

(Dogs naturally eat a bit of grass for nutrients).

You seem like a free thinker Len. Whether I challenged you to keep searching for more information or not, I'm glad you entered the open debate. DOnt' trust anything I say.

If you want to learn more, I recommend the first video in this article. I, as well as a lot of other "virus deniers", happen to think this is one of the best and most captivating for people who are just getting interested in the germ theory debate.

https://boostershots.substack.com/p/virus-denialism-for-beginners-germ

Hope I answered most of your concerns. Please let me know if there's anything else you'd like me to give my opinion on if I missed something.

Keep searching for truth brother.

Andreas Oehler's avatar

https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2022/09/05/massive-rise-in-rabies-cases-kerala.html : "Stray dog menace has increased drastically in the state. Children and the poor are the most common victims of stray dog attacks. Deaths occur despite people taking rabies vaccination..."

Jabbed people, dog reservoirs of Covid. But rabies is real. A virus.

rich's avatar

if your so called viruses actually existed the human race would have become extinct thousands of years ago...from the book of common sense

Happiness: AViewpoint!'s avatar

I agree. Another control mechanism for population growth. Started way way back. Lack of vitamin c and D would manifest weak cell structures for viruses to get in to the cells.

John's avatar

" I think so-called "germ" theory and virus theory are likely correct in general. I don't think "germs" are the main cause of disease. "

There is no virus theory. There is a hypothesis that has no evidence to support it. If you are arguing that germs are NOT the main cause when the hypothesis is that they ARE the main cause then you are trying to have it both ways. Claim there is viruses by shifting the goal posts only to help support criminal activities of poisoning. This is not something that is unimportant because there is actual deaths involved and if you are using fallacious arguments then it could be that you are a party to a crime. If you want to defend the existance of viruses and thus vaccines it needs to be more than oh I feel like computers have viruses or oh but they are not the main cause. This shows you are treating this like a joke or trying to muddy the water. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9AQIm4fEJUM

Len Kinder's avatar

So it's only allowed for people to have one of two views: either they can think germs cause disease or that terrain causes disease. Is that it? We're not allowed to think that both might cause disease? And if we do, we're scheming?

BDev's avatar

Booster - Thanks mucho for all your thought, analyses and writing on this subject. As a doctor of Natural Hygiene, I have been working with patients for >40 years. Have pretty much seen everything under the sun. Bottom line: Disease is a No Show in anyone who is well-nourished, well-rested, reasonably fit and balanced in mind and emotions. Always has been that way and always will be.

That said, as of today I'd say that the reality is 99.9% terrain theory and 0.1% germ theory. Your immune system is certainly incredibly effective in the work it does. Your immune system is the result of a billion years of natural evolution, during which time immune systems across all life forms have seen and dealt with everything imaginable... NATURALLY imaginable. And therein lies the key, I think.

All forms of life, existing in their NATURAL ideal state, are well equipped to handle everything they may encounter. As such, immune systems are primed to effectively and efficiently deal with all toxins and 'pathogens' they may encounter. But this only applies to life in its natural environment, as normally constituted. A natural, balanced ecosystem generates very few if any novel 'pathogens.'

So, if an immune system is suddenly exposed to a toxin or 'pathogen' that is completely off the charts of expected challenges, what happens?

99.9/100 times the immune system handles it, more or less. Your immune system IS finite, after all. Also, when exposed to novel irritants, there is a time lag btw first encounter and eventual effective disabling/elimination of the irritant, as the immune system quickly learns all the permutations of dealing with it. During that time lag, strange and possible destructive things can happen.

So, from my POV, there are the small and abnormally quirky situations where a healthy immune system may not be able to cope with a new/novel irritant/pathogen. At least theoretically, that's how I see it.

So where are potential new/novel 'pathogens/bacteria/viruses' coming from?

From radically imbalanced ecosystems, subsequently diseased animals and people, and an environment filled with all manner of abnormal, severely toxic substances. Now we add in the output of mad scientists who are blindly and ignorantly tinkering with the building blocks of life, creating VERY unnatural frankenmicrobes.

Even in this deranged case, all of Life continues desperately trying to right the wrongs as best it can. With some significant fraction of people, their immune systems cannot cope, and PART of the degenerative process can be attributed to the damage caused by toxic insult of the many novel forms of toxic detritus around and inside them.

Medicine, of course, focuses primarily on that PART, to the exclusion of real causes. Along with constantly playing on fear of invisible monsters. After all, fearfully focusing on that PART is where the money is.

BTW - Very good article that I think you'll find interesting. The number and variety of microbes is staggering... WAY beyond what I previously thought. The author is firmly of pro-virus persuasion. His info is fascinating: https://megasociety.org/noesis/200.pdf

Faith's avatar

Mitichondria are master controllers of the cell, as well as producers of 36/38 of its energy. A fascinating experiment was conducted a while back where healthy/normal ("non-cancerous") nuclei were transplanted into cancer cells after removing their damaged nuclei. All the healthy nuclei also became damaged as in typical cancer cells. Then they reversed the experiment and transplanted damaged, cancerous nuclei into healthy cells, and voilá, the chromosomes were repaired and the "cancer" nuclei became healthy! The difference? The cancerous cells had damaged, poorly functioning mitochondria, and the healthy cells had strong, healthy mitochondria. The cancerous state had nothing to do with the nuclei and everything to do with the health and functionality of the mitochondria. Healthy mitochondria repair damaged chromosomes in cancerous nuclei OR initiate apoptosis to kill the cell if the nuclear damage is beyond repair. Moral to the story? Cancer is all about cellular energy and healthy mitichondria, not bad DNA! Billions of cancer research dollars have been wasted "barking up the wrong tree" of DNA damage instead of studying the real cause of cancer: cellular energy deficit.

Thinkologist's avatar

Weird I click like and it unregistered the like.

LONG In The TRUTH's avatar

.....as to MY insight, Andreas: Professor Gerald Pollack at the University (authored two VITALLY-important books, 'Gel, Cells & The Engines Of Life' as well as MORE so, 'The Fourth Phase Of Water') demonstrated that significant thrust, charge could be provided by SYNTHETIC microtubing in them (through catalyst by infrared radiation playing a PIVOTAL part in supporting cohered organic systems / 'life' through regulation of collagen, telomeric conditions) and presentation videos he did; had FORGOTTEN what Nassim & Theresa Rauscher's novel scaling law had mathematically revealed.....THIS, is the primary focus of work I've been doing this past year (and how an imminent geomagnetic reversal, unprecedented expansion of artificial EMFs & the CV-19 jabs, will / HAVE affected it)......https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U6fKV9M0ymY

Faith's avatar

Sorry. You will have do do a search, but it shouldn't be hard to find because I've seen multiple other sources reference it. I come across so much interesting information, I can't keep track of the sources. Could have been in one of my books about mitochondria. Or mabe it was a journal article itself.

LONG In The TRUTH's avatar

.....my STRONG suspicion is they may be targeting associated MICROTUBULES, which are LIKELY how lifeforms mitigate excess electrical charge, magnetic fields, radiation - as these ARE the MOST bioelectrically reactive concoctions EVER produced, they present an IMMEDIATE instrument for metabolic-process corruption, electron-transport chain efficacy (as Firstenberg HAS noted, is CRITICAL to subjective health.....)

Happiness: AViewpoint!'s avatar

Yes. I think too that weakened cells are defective looking to a virus packet, so it goes in to correct things and signals defensive mechanisms in the body, so inflammation turns on, pain , signaling more defense. It’s worth taking extra C and D and zinc to avoid this.

Faith's avatar

I doubt that viruses are trying to do anything except deliver their genetic payload to hijack cellular protein synthesis machinery to make more copies of themselves. Doing that sets up the cell for destruction, so it certainly isn't trying to "correct things"!

And yes, extra vitamins C and D, and zinc, are important, but supplementing isn't a simple issue. You also need magnesium and vitamin A and other things for the vitamin D to work, and you need a balanced dose of vitamin K2 also. The zinc needs to be balanced with copper or you will make a (very common) copper deficiency worse. But magnesium blocks zinc absorption and so should not be taken at the same time, and only a limited amount of zinc can be absorbed at one time, so high doses must be divided. Same with vitamin C =take in frequent smaller doses. And the body requires other antioxidants such as vitamin E to "recharge" the depleted vitamin C after it does its job as an antioxidant, but must be taken as mixed tocopherols and tocotrienols, NEVER as the common cheap synthetic commercial form of E by itself: alpha tocopherol!

And few adults (except for pregnant or lactating women) need supplemental calcium, which is usually adequate in the diet, and calcium competes with magnesium for absorption, so taking calcium tends to create a magnesium deficiency (and CONTRIBUTE to poor bone health!). Etc. Etc.!!! And yet, modern commercial foods are nearly universally deficient in essential nutrients, so supplementation is required by nearly everyone!

Get the picture? 😊

Faith's avatar

Electron-transport chain efficacy is CRITICAL to OBjective health, too!

Are you talking about the cytoplasmic microtubules as in the ones utilized by the cellular Transport Molecules?

LONG In The TRUTH's avatar

Indeed I am, Faith.....not sure if you've seen the documentary 'Black Whole' but, they have a role only JUST recognized by Nassim Haramein this past decade-plus; it is absolutely AMAZING.....https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aB3Z0SD_Xiw

Len Kinder's avatar

Faith, very interesting. Maybe that's where Dr. Eric Berg on Youtube got the idea that damaged mitochondria cause cancer.

Faith's avatar

I don't know that we can say that damaged mitochondria "cause" cancer as much as that they just can't STOP cancer. Probably cellular damage from toxins, radiation, viruses, free radicals, nutrient deficiencies and so forth can be considered the "causes".

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 6, 2022
Comment deleted
Happiness: AViewpoint!'s avatar

Yes and governments won’t let mds practice holistic and functional medicine without threatening their license, so whoever wants good medicine has to be able to pay a lot. Very sad note to wake up to.

Faith's avatar

Unfortunately, the "useless medical industry" is not useless! It is VERY useful for the transfer of obscene amounts of wealth from the population to the High Priests of Medicine who are part of the Globalist network that's infesting human society.

It is also very effective at population reduction and at making and keeping the majority of the citizens of industrialized nations chronically ill since healthy people are not profitable. Healthy people also can live a long time and overstress the Social Security retirement system (and Medicare) and pension funds. People with chronic diseases typically die in a more timely manner, and since the medical system merely "treats" the symptoms of chronic conditions instead of curing them (by addressing and correcting the root cause[s]), "vulturine" Big Medicine continues to feed off of patients before finally killing them.

Also, it fools people into believing:

(1) that the allopathic Big Pharma-controlled medical system is the "go to" solution for all health concerns.

(2) that they "have" a medical condition (that is actually a collection of symptoms given an official name). That is, they "own it" or internalize it, programming the subconscious mind for illness via the "nocebo effect" (the opposite of placebo).

(3) that doctors "know best" and must be idolized and deferred to ("white lab coat syndrome").

(4) that the treatment recommended by their doctor must be the best possible solution to their problem because doctors are really smart and stay abreast of the latest medical research/knowledge.

(5) that pharmaceutical drugs cure illnesses and it is in the patient’s best interests to take whatever their doctor prescribes, no matter how many or for how long.

David Lamb's avatar

Sorry, but your representation of Cowan's message on virology isn't even remotely accurate. You completely ignore his central, critical point, which is that no so-called human virus has ever been isolated. Considering there's no virus to begin with, talking about supposed problems with looking at a "virus" with an electron microscope is ridiculous.

Your argument that viruses are real because computers get viruses, and "because of the great amount of info that seems to be known about viruses and diseases" is fine if you're satisfied with that, but it's sharing faith and belief, not science.

Interesting that you pinned this comment to the top, Igor. It seems there's an agenda. Too bad you can't see that if what passes for scientific truth progresses further toward becoming a matter of popular approval, science and reason cease to exist, and we're headed much deeper into darkness as a civilization.

rubyred's avatar

A lot of players WISH that viruses cause cancer in fact there is a whole industry built around it.

Find the musings of https://amidwesterndoctor.substack.com/ (I can't find the article link itself) on this very topic which includes the history of how people have been convinced that HPV causes cervical cancer.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 6, 2022
Comment deleted
rich's avatar

HPV... another big pharma scam...a very dangerous one at that

Len Kinder's avatar

You too. I'm learning a lot from people's comments here.

Mystic William's avatar

Your first paragraph makes no sense. A computer does not get a virus. They call it that as a metaphor. This is used because we are all familiar with the term. The term has been ubiquitous. So it was adopted for computers. But it’s simply an analogy; it can’t then be used to draw other conclusions about it.

John's avatar

Eric Berg is a scientologist. His son seems to think he is cashing in on selling supplements and calls his incredibly selfish and devoid of empathy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWZHbxwKTqc

Dr Leo discusses some of his views and says they don't make sense and has no idea where these ideas came from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pnix75yLXqE

Faith's avatar

By the way, if Dr. Leo "has no idea where these ideas came from", he certainly doesn't study much about nutrition!

Faith's avatar

Okay, you got me started, so here goes!:

I watched both of these videos.

First comment: did you notice the attitudes of the presenters? Hardly "scientific". One must be cautious when someone is not merely presenting information but is condescending, snarky, and profusely using an ad hominem attack strategy. What is their agenda? Cui bono?

Secondly, I am not a regular follower of Dr. Berg's work, and I know nothing about him personally. I have come across his videos at times. Regarding the claims he is into Scentology, if true that does make me suspicious of his judgement, but following a cult doesn't mean a person cannot also study a subject and be knowledgeable about it.

Many years ago, out of curiosity I looked into Scientology after encountering some Scientologists. The developer, L.Ron Hubbard, was best known as a science fiction writer, and to me his ideas that form the basis of Scientology are pure science fiction. I tried reading his book, "Dianetics" once, and didn't get very far. I found it to be "unreadable" because it appeared to me to be completely made-up out of "thin air" nonsense. I later heard (and I don't remember where) that he admitted that he just made it all up. I guess that shouldn't be surprising coming from a writer of science fiction.

I don't know who "Dr. Leo" is, but I'm guessing he is a vegan who has bought into the "Religion of Veganism", judging from his misinformation about meat. This is, of course, the "religion" adopted by the Globalists to justify their anti-human Global Warming "climate change" agenda to make humans unhealthy, incapable of producing healthy children, and dumbed down to make them easier to control and exterminate.

Much of "science" these days is agenda-driven and is, frankly, "junk science". We have certainly seen that surrounding COVID and the "vaccines"! One has to look at who's funding the research. Who is making claims such as "scientific concensus"? (There really is no such thing.) What opposing views are being censored? (THOSE are most likely to be "the truth"!) And what scientists or dictors are being attacked and demonized for their views? Again, most often the ones disseminating "the truth". (I put "the truth" in quotes because science is never "settled", and our knowledge base is constantly expanding as new research modifies or replaces older ideas.)

I could spend many hours throughly dissecting Leo's arguments, but there is certainly no room here, nor will I take the time. However, I will say that much of what he is presenting are very outdated and thoroughly disproven ideas. He is also "cherry picking" out partial "truths" to try to support his position. For instance, there has been a widely disseminated idea that saturated fat is unhealthy. This was based on junk "research" funded by Big Ag to promote the use of corn oil (cheap, plentiful byproduct that needed a profitable use) and other cheap industrial seed oils. A researcher named Ancel Keys was funded by industry to conduct research "proving" that animal fat is unhealthy and causes heart disease. The entire enterprise was fraudulent, but it formed the basis for the demonization of animal fats (and later, animal products in general —a key position of the Globalists). It was the entire basis for the push to get people to believe in, and consume, polyunsaturated seed oils, promoted as healthy-sounding "vegetable oils", probably the single worst dietary change in history and responsible for untold millions of deaths and disabilities! It is a "toss up" whether the worst thing you can eat is sugar or seed oils, but probably the winner in the "worst" category would be the oils. The most dangerous thing about a junk food diet is the high quantities of oils in all forms, including hydrogenated versions.

There is zero valid evidence that saturated fats from healthy grass fed animals eating the way they were intended, and not full of antibiotics and hormones, is harmful. IF saturated fat actually caused heart disease WE WOULD ALL BE DEAD because guess what kind of fat predominantly exists in our bodies? Saturated! It HAS to be, because it is stiffer and STABLE, necessary qualities to make up most of our cell membranes and stored energy in adipose tissue. Every time someone loses weight, or just burns some of their stored fat for energy, they are using primarily saturated fat, just as if they had just eaten and digested it!

There are SO many misconceptions out there. Propaganda, really. Fat and heart disease? "Clogged" arteries? Arteries are not water pipes like the plumbing in your house. They don't "clog up" with deposits filling them up like hard water mineral deposits in pipes! And they definitely don't clog up with "cholesterol deposits"! If you still believe that, you are very badly misinformed. Cholesterol does NOT "cause" heart disease! (And carbon dioxide is NOT a "pollutant" that "causes" global warming!) Very bad people are promoting a huge amount of nonsense to push through very destructive agendas!

Cholesterol is not bad! It is an extremely important molecule that makes up a significant portion of our brains, and is a critical component of all cell membranes, the precursor molecule for many of our hormones including vitamin D, a detoxifier, and is very important for immune system function. And guess what? The people in the quartile with the highest cholesterol LIVE THE LONGEST!!!!

Eggs? Probably the most complete single food. Very healthy, except possibly for a slightly higher than ideal level of arachidonic acid, but even that is not the bad actor that some sources try to make out that it is! Nutrition and biochemistry are SOOOO complex!

These are just a few examples of how off base is Dr. Leo, and that what he is espousing is mostly soundly disproven by recent advances in nutritional research! Conversely, almost everything that Dr. Berg presented in those video excerpts was the most up to date science. But again, knowledge is constantly being added to. Current ideas will be expanded upon in the future, and some will be supplanted. But that is what science all about, not personal attacks and snarky attitudes! And why is he picking on chiropractors, anyway? They sometimes do a lot more good for people than traditional M.D.s, those drug-pushing flunkeys for Big Pharma who mostly know almost nothing about nutrition OR health, just disease diagnosis and maintenance! Yes, I can have "an attitude" too!

John's avatar

"This is, of course, the "religion" adopted by the Globalists."

The allocation of most all land and vast sums of subsidies to put cheap flesh on peoples plates says otherwise. You are making an argument that is the exact oppositite of the reality of the food being pushed on people. Why do you think youtube would be sending Berg so many viewers if they wanted to promote veganism? Reality is that flesh eating has been pushed for thousands of years and is now being pushed to the even greater extremes of keto and the carnivore diet. Take Paul for example who told Christians to eat what ever they found in the market without raising any concerns.

" what scientists or dictors are being attacked and demonized for their views? Again, most often the ones disseminating "the truth"."

T Colin Campbell was misrepresented by the BBC for example but there is also lots of people calling vegans "soy boys" etc. which I would say is demonization:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OnQfXvOap9c

Faith's avatar

Flesh eating is not "being pushed for thousands of years". It has been the NORMAL DIET of humans for hundreds of thousands of years. Not agricultural products. Not grains. Not soybeans. Certainly not seed oils and sugar.

"The allocation of most all land". Not true. Worldwide almost all grazing is done on land unsuitable for crop production. Much of the planet cannot be farmed because of topgraphy, shallow or poor soils, salinity, drought, or other problems. Most cropping systems as currently practiced are unsustainable because of soil degradation and erosion, irrigation that adds salinity to the soil, the drawing down and destruction of aquifers via very deep wells harvesting ancient and non-replaceable water, loss of biodiversity, use of pesticides, runoff of toxins and fertilizers destroying aquatic habitats, etc. Animal agricultural allows the most nutritious foods for humans to be produced from cellulosic plant matetials unusable/undigestible by us from land that is otherwise unusable.

The Globalist plan is to kill off the rest of us with ultra-processed utterly fake "foods" made from grain, soybeans, seed oils, and insects. A recipe for rampant disease and suffering, lowered intelligence, and Mass Depopulation.

T. Colin Campbell manipulated the data to supoort the Globalist agenda . . . and, of course it was in China, with the help of the Communist Chinese. Gee, what a surprise!

Mojo Cuba's avatar

lemme just paste this here ;-)

i can see what the problem is here : if you look at this cdc linked paper on the methods of "isolation" https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/26/6/20-0516_article : - and i quote : "Cell Culture, Limiting Dilution, and Virus Isolation

We used Vero CCL-81 cells for isolation and initial passage. We cultured Vero E6, Vero CCL-81, HUH 7.0, 293T, A549, and EFKB3 cells in Dulbecco minimal essential medium (DMEM) supplemented with heat-inactivated fetal bovine serum (5% or 10%) and antibiotics/antimycotics (GIBCO, https://www.thermofisher.comExternal Link). We used both NP and OP swab specimens for virus isolation. For isolation, limiting dilution, and passage 1 of the virus, we pipetted 50 μL of serum-free DMEM into columns 2–12 of a 96-well tissue culture plate, then pipetted 100 μL of clinical specimens into column 1 and serially diluted 2-fold across the plate. We then trypsinized and resuspended Vero cells in DMEM containing 10% fetal bovine serum, 2× penicillin/streptomycin, 2× antibiotics/antimycotics, and 2× amphotericin B at a concentration of 2.5 × 105 cells/mL. We added 100 μL of cell suspension directly to the clinical specimen dilutions and mixed gently by pipetting. We then grew the inoculated cultures in a humidified 37°C incubator in an atmosphere of 5% CO2 and observed for cytopathic effects (CPEs) daily. We used standard plaque assays for SARS-CoV-2, which were based on SARS-CoV and Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) protocol"

- do you see how many antobiotics and chemicals they use? how can you be sure what comes out is an isolated virus? instead of some toxic crap, or even some mutated rna?

to be honest i do not know christine, but if you really want you should seek out Dr Andrew kaufman : he will be willing to debate on video. and that should be fascinating to be honest. give him a call.

- here is a teaser on his position from april 2020 : https://youtu.be/K3uFmriAQ0Y

John's avatar

What comes out is not an isolated virus. It is decaying material. The same experiment can be conducted without adding any swab specimens. No supposedly infected samples added and it still produces the same decaying material. These control experiments should have been done before anyone claimed they showed a virus: https://odysee.com/@OurFreeSociety:2/CPE---Control-Experiment---21-April-2021---English-version:0

Agent 1-4-9's avatar

I used to think viruses exist because that's what I was taught and experience seems to confirm it. I've seen the same sickness travel through my family on many occasions. But I'll admit the "no such thing as a virus" people have some good points. I think there is some kind of dance between terrain and pathogen that we don't fully understand yet and more study is needed. Kind of a weasel opinion, I know, but I feel like that's where we are.

Igor Chudov's avatar

Good, so you are an open minded person in search of evidence

Agent 1-4-9's avatar

Absolutely. Not so open minded that I don't have any settled opinions, but I'm willing to listen.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Steve Kirsch's avatar

no they don't have good points. I have listen very patiently to their points and they make no sense. they refuse to go on camera with me for even 5 minutes.

Rebecca's avatar

That's because there is no point in more debate. What we need are real scientific experiments done with transparency and without agenda.

AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

They've been done thousands of times over. The sum of the results only has one coherent explanation, and the 'no-virusers' haven't come up with an alternative one that holds-together.

Mystic William's avatar

I don’t need to solve a problem better than your solution. All I have to do is show how yours is wrong.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
SmithFS's avatar

There is a much easier experiment. Get a few no-virus types. They are absolutely certain in their views. Get them to volunteer to go to an Ebola infected African region. Prove their beliefs and treat & supply care to Ebola victims, but unlike any of the other staff, no gloves, no moon suit. Should be easy, it is largely a virus that transmits through bodily fluids, so it should be no problem. Just think what a heroic deed. All these Africans who run for their lives when they see an Ebola infected person wandering the streets. All for nada. Just get this fellow ie_berger to show them the truth. "There is no virus folks, relax, don't worry. I'll grab this Ebola infected person, tell him he's fine, he just needs supplements, fresh water, fresh air. Cured."

Len Kinder's avatar

Experiments have already been done. Knowledge is out there. We just need to go gather it up.

Please give it to me,'s avatar

Nothing of consequence to add, but just wanted to tell you the phrase 'the best a mouse could know' has delighted me. Thetans, viruses, morgellons, ect...it's 'maybe' from me, dawgs.

David Lamb's avatar

They refuse to go on camera with you because you're trying to arrange a set-up. All one need do to understand that is read the comments here. The comments that essentially say "I know there's a virus because people get sick." are overwhelmingly popular, because the familiar belief is far more comfortable than something foreign and belief-disruptive. You and they already know that you win the popularity contest, because you have the more conventional, comfortable view. There is no space for science in that arena, and I think you know that. You're revealing yourself to be just another soldier in the war against science.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
David Lamb's avatar

Thanks. Yep, I follow Jon and read all his stuff. Good man.

I'm not gonna try to analyze Steve. Yeah, he appears to be unable to muster the courage to open his mind and admit that he's missed something big, but he's stuck in a powerful belief system along with everyone else, and maybe he'll wake up one morning and suddenly decide to 'wake up'.

I learned a long time ago, from my father, that the self-promoting smartest guy in the room is only that because the guy who's far smarter walked out the moment he saw the talker and his groupies coming. The really, really smart people tend to detest politics and the superficialities of social norms, and don't talk much. You have to earn their respect before they'll say anything. In this age of runaway superficiality, people laugh at the most enlightened and rally around the most vain and materialistic. Tough times to be advocating detestable things like science and truth...

Mystic William's avatar

I’m not saying SK is this, but I l know a few super fast, but not super great intellects, who because they process really quickly think they are smarter than they actually are. Some are volatile but good in business. I’d be curious if Steve has psoriasis. A number of these super fast ones have psoriasis. That sounds odd I bet.

Frances Leader's avatar

You have abused us. Me, in particular. You said my work is ridiculous and you sneered at my low numbers of subscribers when I had been de-platformed from all social media and only just started writing on Substack. THEN you banned me from your account for 100 years. You have been far from patient. You have been offensive and denying us an opportunity to debate.

Now you whine that we won't go on camera with you?

You do not merit our attention.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Frances Leader's avatar

I have told you all he said to me. He said my work is ridiculous and he could see why I had so few subscribers. There was no other communication.

I had tried to draw his attention to my email exchange with UK MHRA as shown in this article:

https://francesleader.substack.com/p/sarscov2-mrna-is-synthetic

Karin B's avatar

Have seen some nasty messages to you. I'm sorry. People have gone mad.

Here is a video by Dr. Trozzi and he does a good job deflating the "no virus" hypothesis.

https://drtrozzi.org/2022/09/05/germ-terrain-reality-is-sars-cov2-real/

David Lamb's avatar

He does a "good job" because he says what you want to hear?

I watched the video, and he completely ignores the central point made by the virology challengers whom Steve has ridiculed. Part of his explanation is accurate, but his critical omission is that the previous SARS genomes that he says Cov-2 is similar to are also all computer simulations, with not one of them ever isolated or sequenced. If you cared to follow the trail backward, there's not one virus ever that's been isolated or sequenced. The propagandistic photos they show don't change that fact. Every 'virus' genome in the Genebank is a computer simulation of a theoretical 'virus'. So his argument boils down to using previous fictitious virus genomes to supposedly prove that the newest fictional genome is something real. And he adds emphasis with 'these sequencing machines are really high-tech and amazing so you should have faith in what I'm saying...'.

The video may be impressive to those who haven't put in the work to understand the science issues, but he says nothing credible to refute the fact that no human virus has ever been isolated or sequenced, and therefore has not been proven to exist.

Jo Scraba's avatar

Really well put — when I learned all virus sequencing was done in silica using modeling algorithms, I decided the whole field was smoke and mirrors. Another iteration of NASA.

John's avatar

"It is one of the risk factors for covid-19". err no covid 19 is defined as being caused by sars-cov2. There is no room for any other factors in the definition.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 6, 2022
Comment deleted
Matthew Hajzl's avatar

these are the same arguments atheists use to prove God doesn't exist.

much of what we call science is derivative. it does not offer us the direct experience of truth or proof.

however not understanding something does not mean it does not exist.

Karin B's avatar

Steve, please note my comment near the beginning:

"I'm in the "have no idea" category. I made a comment in Karen Bracken's substack a few days ago where she posted comments by Poornima Wagh (who claims there is no virus). I suggested she (Karen) reconsider her position and read Steve Kirsch's substack where he said he tried to phone Poornima several times and she never called him back. Karen came back to me with: 'Steve Kirsch did not try multiple times to get an interview with Poornima. She called him 3 times and he never called her back. Understand she is exposing the criminals and we all should know by now when someone doesn’t stick to the script then go after that person to erase them and to destroy them. Someone posts a hit piece and then the rest of the click baiters post it on their sites. Believe what you want.' So, we have a he said/she said! Maybe Steve can show his phone log to prove his attempts to reach her. I have no inside to Steve. Can anyone do that? I think it would be interesting, so we know who is telling the truth on that tit for tat. I'd be inclined to settle on the truth teller for my information. Thanks for your persistence and countless hours of analysis."

sk's avatar

Aren't you the guy who peddled the vax until you didn't? Or am I confusing you with someone else?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
SmithFS's avatar

I would be more inclined to believe the no-virus types are CIA shills. A typical CIA "poisoning the well" strategy. If there is no virus then of course the CIA did not have Covid-19 engineered and deliberately spread it around the World, so the $trillionaires can get even more wealthy and powerful as they did, enormously more.

David Lamb's avatar

The "no-virus" types have been around as long as the Rockefeller-created fiction of viruses. Obviously you don't pay attention.

So supposing the population turns off the entertainment and learns about virology instead, figures out that it's a con, and the global Rockefeller medical/pharma cartel collapses, that makes them more wealthy & powerful? Wow, genius.

Frances Leader's avatar

That is an offensive accusation. We genuinely believe that virology is mistaken after careful research.

https://francesleader.substack.com/p/all-my-substack-articles-on-emfc19

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Stephanie B.'s avatar

I still think that's weaseling out. It makes me think they don't want to go on video because they don't want to be questioned and challenged. In writing, they can ramble on indefinitely without being challenged. Nope, it needs to be a video. Submit written supporting materials if you want but also appear on video.

Mystic William's avatar

I think the video is less convincing. Good weaselly facile speaker people can twist words and never answer anything. Two people write good clear arguments. Post them simultaneously. Then each gets to rebut the other. Then everyone votes. I don’t see how that cannot be the best.

guest1.6's avatar

Bingo. Have you noticed how the "written is better" camp derides the spontaneous and live debate (video) as if they were for the "unwashed masses"?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Faith's avatar

Words can be easily edited to change the meaning. Pretty hard to do with a video taken with just one camera.

Ellen's avatar

Would a discussion on this with Dr Richard Fleming, and / or Dr Byram Bridle / Geert Vanden Bossche be possible? (Or the doctors treating covid)?

Len Kinder's avatar

I don't trust Geert, since he worked for Gates.

Mystic William's avatar

How about this? Dead cellular debris can be toxic, when expelled from a toxic Ill person. And maybe sick cell material can be inhaled by a healthy person. It can’t get into a cell and replicate but it can cause the receiver to lose whichever cell it touches. This then causes the receiver a need to expel the original toxic material plus his own now dead cell. And so he coughs or sneezes. More like an allergic reaction to a sick person rather than transmitting a disease.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 6, 2022
Comment deleted
Greg C's avatar

Steve got awful quiet in a hurry, didn't he?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Sophocles's avatar

Actually no. I can read faster than people speak so I prefer to read. Unless I am driving or something at the same time, in which case audio is the best format.

Mcc's avatar

I would read . Frankly I believe most people seriously curious about this debate at all would read it.

The Mallorn Tree's avatar

I'd read that. I'm sure many people will. There's still lots of people that can read on this planet. I like video discussions as well, but writing allows one to thoughtfully consider the other's claims and respond more calmly and precisely. Video tends to encourage demagoguery and emotional appeals.

That's not to say Steve would engage in that kind of rhetoric, but it may be the reason why Lanka and others preferred to write, and I don't see why that shouldn't be accepted. Traditionally, when someone throws the glove, the other side gets to choose the weapon ;-)

Harmen's avatar

If a written debate is nessecary to get this debate off the ground, then we'll start there. Than a video can be made later. I know I would read, I did not dive into the topic, I think terrain theory is abundantly clear, but also infectiveness!

Charles Clemens's avatar

Everyone is different. Given the option of reading a transcript or watching a video, I will always choose the written transcript.

Janet's avatar

I prefer reading. I can concentrate more than the videos. Audio and reading works better for me.

shibumi's avatar

The person interviewed could also *claim* their responses were forged.

Instead of on camera, perhaps a podcast debate?

John Sbrochi's avatar

I agree with this. While "we" might read it , the masses would not. Video would reach more people - like comparing YouTube to Substack.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
brideofMoshiach's avatar

We are spiritual beings having a physical experience.

Health and sickness is a topic much more complex than a study of particles.

Just read the Bible.

It is not a weasel opinion, it is realistic.

Phil Welsh's avatar

Then there's the issue of bio-resonance. Being within a sick person's energy field (said to extend a minimum of six feet from the body) can influence your own health in profound ways. The longer the contact, the greater the "entrainment" to achieve a more balanced rhythm/sympathetic resonance between the two bodies. Interesting number, that 6. Wasn't that the suggested social distancing standard during "the evil COVID pandemic"? Did "they" not want us to be in close contact because "they" know this resonance phenomenon operates equally well when one is in the presence of healthy people? Just sayin'...

Faith's avatar

The size of auric fields allegedly varies greatly. Some people have huge fields, but I can "pick up on" peoples' energy from quite a distance regardless.

The 6 feet antisocial distance was made up out of thin air. Supposedly it was as far as they thought they could get away with imposing, without people balking at it too much, and as far as was feasible to implement inside of buildings. Real "scientific", huh? Like ALL of Fauci’s fake "science".

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

Smellofields are the real truth and next frontier. I know to avoid people with certain smells.

S. Anderson's avatar

Can you get herpes from being within six feet of someone's energy field? I didn't realize that herpes was just a "vibe."

Frances Leader's avatar

Herpes could be a blood parasite. Of course THEY are transmissable.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Charles Clemens's avatar

There will always be those who deny the effects of faith on disease. I once took a class called Mental Hygeine and the professor stated that primitive people who believe in witch doctors or shamans do about as well as those who believe in Allopathic medicine. Similarly, many people scoff at the efficacy of homeopathic medicine. Yet it is my personal experience that, after suffering from airborne allergies for 73 years, I discovered a homeopathic remedy that made the mucus disappear. Placebo effect? Who cares.

As a CPS Worker, I often found my mind behaving oddly when I was forced to interact with paranoid schizophrenics. Was it my fear or was it the auras of these sick individuals that caused mental feedback in my brain?

We live in a spiritual universe disguised as physical. Just as quantum physics has proven that nothing makes sense at a micro level, we must accept the fact that very little makes sense at the macro level.

Faith's avatar

Video shows droplets expelled from sneezes traveling as far as 23 feet, but viral particles are much tinier than droplets and float nearly indefinitely on air currents indoors, making the 6 feet distance useless and absurd.

Faith's avatar

There is no such thing as "physical" matter. Everything is energy and we currently have part of our consciousness focused into this gigantic holographic illusion. We are spiritual beings having a spiritual experience in an illusion of physicality. The Bible is an illusion. Lol!

Former UK resident's avatar

Haha quite. This is a simulation based universe.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Faith's avatar

Technically, yes. But it also would spoil the purpose of bothering to enter into a physical body in the first place. But there is "no such thing as death" since YOU, the CONSCIOUSNESS existed before entry into a physical body, and continues to exist after going back out. Consciousness does not arise from "unconscious" atoms and molecules. (Even though the consciousness of the Quantum Field permeates and affects all matter.)

Former UK resident's avatar

I'm lost. Does the Bible refer to things like viruses and bacterias specifically?

Since you mention it, I will ask my three book religion friends to see what their religious takes are. (I'm not into organised religion).

I see the mantra we are spiritual beings having a physical experience, quoted over and over. Then in effect, any experience can be spiritual, no ? So I guess, having a discussion about viruses could be spiritual as well as doing domestic chores....

AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

Bible advises to reject pharmakea - which is folks selling quack cures.

Former UK resident's avatar

I think we are derailing from the main theme of this discussion - the viruses exist or not.

Also if the medicine doesn't work for you, why should you wish to take it ? Do we need to consult the Bible for that ?

brideofMoshiach's avatar

I was mainly referring to Yeshua's healing ministry.

If you had an OBE, as I did, or an NDE, as many people did, you make the first-hand experience of the ... mantra, as you called it.

Former UK resident's avatar

I see. i know people who had the mantra experiences without an OBE or a NDE. Why are people so attached to 'forms'?

AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

Bible says to reject the quacks (pushers pharmakea).

It's a good default position to hold, even today after we have accumulated so much knowledge of biology.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

That's also false. Maybe you just type feelings instead of thoughts.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
brideofMoshiach's avatar

The Bible was just meant as an example - you yourself refer to Hinduism (!) - by the way a religion very close to my heart.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
John Sbrochi's avatar

Can you give an example of the unnamed state? I'm unclear what you are referencing. Thanks you.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Bigs's avatar

Viruses are in a sense a parasite that uses the host's own cells for reproduction, via the same mechanism that we produce our own proteins. It's a very mechanical process and (reasonably) understood

Mystic William's avatar

But they’re not alive. How can they ‘do’ anything? Also as Photons says no virus has ever been properly isolated. If they exist why can’t anyone find one?

Level The Matrix's avatar

I NO LONGER BELIEVE IN VIRAL THEORY OF DISEASE. I came to this conclusion on my own after years of research and before it became a popular topic of discussion. I focused more on proper nutrition and as a result came to understand what the primary underlying cause is.

As far as illnesses traveling through families, as a mother who raised 4 children, I can tell you that isn’t always true in most cases. It does happen, but let me explain below.

What leads to illness and disease is nutritional deficiencies that make us susceptible to developing something or “catching” something. For instance, I always ate and fed my children, all (mostly) healthy adults now. Because my children were rarely nutrient deficient, they didn’t get sick a lot, but it did happen. I rarely got sick when they were and could trace my illness back to either eating poorly, failing to supplement adequately or lack of proper sleep, sunshine or exercise.

Mostly, but not always, nutritional deficiencies travel through families, often bcz families tend to have the same dietary habits or patterns. Long standing nutritional deficiencies often lead to “genetically inherited diseases” run in families. It can take several generations to repair a severe nutritional deficiency in a family line.

Families and communities also tend to get exposed to toxins in groups, so that can lead to illness or disease. Foods are largely seasonal, sun exposure is seasonal depending on where one lives. We all should know by now how nutrient deficient foods are today, particularly those grown from commercial farming practices. Even organic non gmo foods are not as nutrient dense as 4-5 decades ago. Essentially, we are all nutrient deficient today in some form or fashion.

I used to develop symptoms of depression and low energy in the winter months when I lived up north. It is known as SADD or Seasonal Affective Disorder. However, having moved back to Florida 10 years ago, I do not have this issue as long as I spend time in the sunshine regularly. I learned several years after moving up north that if I kept my vitamin D levels high by taking about 30,000iu daily of D3 w K2 and/or going tanning 2-3 times a week, I could prevent developing symptoms of SAD. It never did not work. It has also worked for everyone who I’ve shared this information with and who does the same.

Another factor is the toxic exposures we have. Vaccines are a huge problem. They’re not only highly toxic, they cause severe and rapid depletion of nutrients in the body that further exacerbate susceptibility to and development of illness and disease. Toxic assaults cause the body to go into overdrive to correct the problems as rapidly as possible to return us to good health. When the nutrients aren’t available, the body can’t do its job to make that happen. With children, they’re under constant assault from regular vaccine visits (aka well child visits) to the pediatricians office. They’re also largely fed crap diets at home and at school. Little wonder they get sick so much. Unvaccinated, homeschooled children generally have robust good health.

The body is an amazing machine. It is built using nutrients. It certainly isn’t built using toxic chemical food and drugs. Our bodies always strive to keep us in good health. It can only do that properly when it has adequate nutrients.

Deficiencies and toxins drive disease. Parasites and molds can also drive disease. We really need to stop parroting the narrative of the pharmaceutical and medical industries. The longer we continue to carry water for these criminals, the longer we will continue to fund our own demise.

Harmen's avatar

You just explained terrain theory. I agree with that.

But how do you explain that groups of people getting are getting the same disease that seems infectious? And that it "goes around"? That doctors can say, yeah there is a nasty flu going around that produces your specific symptoms.

Quinbus51's avatar

Great question! Did you know that we really don't know how, specifically, atoms work or even what they look like? We have the model that we were all taught in Chemistry with all the little electrons orbiting around the ball of protons and neutrons, but most physicists are pretty sure that model is way too simplistic--it's much more complex than that.

But working from a flawed model doesn't mean that we can't do effective chemistry, its just that there is a black box we don't really fully understand where our inputs go and expected outcomes happen, but we really don't know what's happening in there. We've got lots of similar models regarding things like health, too.

Science works from models all the time and periodically somebody comes along and points out that the model isn't working anymore. Happened to Newton's basic laws. Newer observations come along (like Particle Physics) that start to question what had been accepted science for many years. Einstein was reportedly deeply disturbed by the ramifications of quantum mechanics ("God doesn't play dice with the universe") but wishing something to be true doesn't mean it is.

Now this line of reasoning might suggest to some that I'm arguing in support of Germ Theory. But actually I've moved to the camp that says there are some fundamental flaws in the Germ model. Turns out the model we all have been taught has some glaring holes in it. Something else is going on that is far more integrative than the simplistic "get a shot every year and you'll be fine" model. In fact, it's becoming glaringly obvious that the commercial ramifications associated with Germ Theory are driving "solutions" that are much more harmful than we have accepted for years. We've reached a tipping point, both in terms of money and individual health, that suggests this approach is no longer sustainable. It never was, actually, but now the mound of evidence has risen to a level where we can begin to see that problems, and COVID, for many of us, was the straw that broke the camel's back. Something is REALLY wrong with the favored model.

The terrain theory proponents are actually offering a much more integrated and elegant solution that, when applied, leads AWAY from commerce and side-effects and toxicity and back toward what we all, in our heart, have known: Health and well-being doesn't (yea, CAN'T) come from a hypodermic needle. Dis-ease is more about what we've done to ourselves than any "germ." THEY are not the villians here, WE are.

Look around you on the street everyday. You don't have to be a doctor to see that people, as a whole, are profoundly unwell. Obesity is rampant along with stressed lifestyles that we all know in our heart are toxic to human wellness. Money and greed are huge drivers of our sickness, but so is ego and ruthless pursuit of What I Want, the rest be damned. Relationships are in tatters--we fight and scream and accuse each other instead of working on what we know is Wrong With Me. Can you look in the mirror and honestly say that you are well?

And then we run to the altar of Medicine. Make us well, priest! Fix our problems with pills, injections and therapies. But NEVER tell ME to do something like change my diet or daily habits!

Terrain theory, as I understand it, is attempting to address the root causes of human suffering.

Hint: It's us.

Faith's avatar

Right on!

Couldn't have said it better myself!

Now the evidence is coming out "fast and furious" that vaccinations are accompanied by a whole host of immunological problems like antigenic priming and overstressing the immune system.

All biologic processes require energy and resources, and if the body expends its resources creating useless, "out-of-date" antibodies, it has less ability to make newer "models" when challenged with a new or mutated pathogen. And then you have the extremely harmful COVID bioweapon "vaccines" that cause production of bioweapon spikes that actually damage the immune system and destroy T-cells and Toll-like Receptors that are crucial to protection from pathogens and cancers. Can we say, "CRAZY"?

John Davison's avatar

Brilliant analysis of what is totally wrong with "The Science"/aka modern medicine.

I have no clue as to what is right re health - but I'm sure Bigpharma ain't the answer.

Wake up you bloody morons.

JustANobody's avatar

Terrain theory is the simplier explanation. I think ' they' try to make us believe what they want with alot of mumbo jumbo.

Len Kinder's avatar

Just as computer code can get a virus, it's plausible that genetic code can get a virus.

Level The Matrix's avatar

Vibrational resonance. We all effect each other. We are not islands until ourselves. The same way you can walk into a room feel the energetic vibration of peoples moods on a cognizant level, the body picks up on energetic vibrations, exposure to toxic levels of EMF’s and will react to it.

Low vibrational feelings and emotions like anger, fear, anxiety all breed lower vibrational levels that are measurable in the same way that higher levels of positive feelings and emotions cause people to feel good. The entire earth and all in, on, and above it vibrate. Everything is resonate frequencies.

Frances Leader's avatar

You are right. A detoxing person sends the impetus to others. It is a beautiful thing.

Faith's avatar

And are "colds" just made up? (Well, they ARE pretty much "all in the head"! Lol!)

SOMETHING is contageous and gets transmitted from person to person!

JustANobody's avatar

I think she did explain it. Look at our chemicals in land, sea and air. All the spraying in our air leads to poor nutrition. Also most are vaccinated and have been as a child. That doesn't just go away. I believe all our health problems start there, dirty electricity, chemicals and EMF's to name a few.

Harmen's avatar

Yes I agree on that too.

But that does not explain the typical infectiveness that can be seen and are attributed to virusses. And why are symptoms in a certain time period the same for people that have completely different toxin exposures? And a few months later, some other infection goes around and then people get different symptoms? Are all these people exposed to the same toxin in the same time period? I can not imagine that. How would that happen?

John Davison's avatar

I agree with the point you make but I also think how does one explain that some people similarly exposed, don't fall ill at all, ever?

Stephanie B.'s avatar

It's not all or nothing people. The no-virus crowd thinks that EVERYONE needs to get sick from exposure or a virus isn't real. That's faulty logic. People are more susceptible to viruses for a variety of reasons, including what was written above, but just because some people may be stronger than others, it does not follow that viruses aren't real.

Jaye's avatar

My doc will say "X (something non-infectious) is bad this year". It's not just germs that "get around". Allergies, myalgias, still point to terrain...just as non-vaccine preventable diseases diminished along with "vaccine-preventable" in the early years of the 20th century do

Harmen's avatar

Those examples are not infectious diseases.

Allergies are a good example of terrain and "problematic" substance. Both are needed to explain real world observations.

Mcc's avatar

I agree with you completely here. I am my own N of 1 study In this regard and at 55 and no longer on any meds and eating properly etc… with my head screwed on straight all my former maladies are gone .I’ve not become sick in years. When I start to feel funky I immediately assess: food? Sun? Stress? Belief? I’m always able to balance the scales back to health.

Faith's avatar

High vitamin D keeps me from getting the flu and most colds, but it sure didn't keep me from getting COVID!

Len Kinder's avatar

Were your Covid symptoms worse than normal flu? MejBCart seems to be finding that the weaponized Covid virus can cause depletion of several amino acids, if I understand her right. I'm trying to learn how the vaxes increase the risk for getting Covid. And I'm not sure if the amino acids depletion can be fixed simply by devouring more complete proteins.

Fizzygurl's avatar

I’m of the same logic, was taught the existence of viruses...so now I’m in that phase that I don’t believe much of what we were told. So no viruses for me.

Horace the Menace's avatar

I don't think that qualifies as logic :-).

Now you have realized that we are taught many things that are not true, I think you can reasonably shift to a "not sure" state, but I do not think you can *logically* shift to a "sure not" state.

Dr Linda's avatar

I have been wondering as well. I read about exosomes and cellular debris. Maybe there is something we just don’t quite get. Perhaps we have a simple answer, virus, for a far more complex question or maybe the opposite, a complex answer for a simple question. I find this fascinating. I work with deep sea bacteria, as deep as 10,000 meters. It was believed that “life” couldn’t exist under those conditions. Life or artifact? Well, it replicated, it had specific DNA sequences. Interesting.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Sep 5, 2022
Comment removed
Dr Linda's avatar

I am not sure if this directed to me or what the intention was. I didn’t say I agree or disagree; just wondering. What a thing to say.

Weihan Xing's avatar

Sorry. No, in fact my comment was directed at someone who had commented with unerring certainty that viruses do not exist, and that no one had ever succeeded in demonstrating person-to-person transmission. I don't know why my comment appears directed at you, so my apologies.

rich's avatar

why dont you kiss someone whos intelligent and see if you get smarter?...if viruses" existed and "caused disease" the human race wouldve been extinct long ago... from the book of common sense

Olle Durks's avatar

I agree with you Don. When we were kids (I'm 66 now) our parents arranged for us to have a day out with our cousins or friends when they had childhood diseases that we hadn't had yet. It took a day or two and we were infected. I did the same with my children. Now whether it is terrain or pathogen I can't say but if I had to take a guess I would say just like fleas jump from one host to the next, there is something in sick persons that do the same.

Weihan Xing's avatar

Have you ever had chickenpox, herpes zoster, measles, mumps, mononucleosis?

John's avatar

"I've seen the same sickness travel through my family on many occasions."

I've seen 3 people bump into eachother in a crowded event wearing the same t shirt. Statistically it is hightly likely that you can flip dice with 10 heads in a row if you flip dice for long enough. If you are only paying attention to the times you saw someone with the same t shirt or when they had a cold then you are not counting all the other times that they didn't have the same t shirt or 'catch a cold'. That is a bias based on the belief in contagion when it is statistically likely to happen on occasion especially if there is cold weather or other factors increasing the odds at certain times. Perhaps the belief itself can increase the odds since there will be a conviction that they are highly likely to get sick. Something called a nocebo effect.

Derren Brown - 10 Heads in a Row (explanation):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1SJ-Tn3bcQ

Beckie Takacs's avatar

I don't think that's correct. Those of us, and there are many, paying attention, do notice a relationship because it actually is happening. None of what I observe behaves like any toxin. Anyone who thinks it's all about toxins don't know what toxic exposure looks like.

John's avatar

How do you explain 'faith healing'?

Derren Brown " explained how the "personal psychological experience that people are going through" results in people believing they've been healed during his performance. Many in the audience would voluntarily come to the front of the theatre shows and testify to being healed."

https://premierchristian.news/en/news/article/derren-brown-reveals-faith-healing-trick

If the belief in healing can be so powerful why not the belief that you are around 'infected' family members and bound to get sick?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FEYW2vqqNDQ

Beckie Takacs's avatar

First, we have no idea if Brown is correct,. Second, you don't start your life knowing anything about infection or contagion, you learn over time from the observation after it happens.

Beckie Takacs's avatar

Terrain has always been important regardless of the pathogen.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022Edited
Comment deleted
Brandon is not your bro's avatar

Heeee Hawww Heidi Heil Right on 🎯

Boostershots's avatar

Heidi,

There is no misconception that I'm aware of.

It is entirely possible for someone to fully embrace germ theory AND terrain theory simultaneously. This would be an extreme and unlikely example, but still possible.

Such a person would adhere to the notion that chemicals, EMF, psychological stress, diet, etc are all critically important to the safety of our health, just like any terrain theory supporter would agree with, yet this person would ALSO fully adhere to the notion that all of the "viruses" and other imaginary biological "pathogens" are "real" and harmful, in addition.

A mouse in the wildness must worry about foxes, hawks, and wolves, pollution, diet, stress, weather, etc, but the mouse never has to worry about "deadly unicorns who also eat mice", or "contagious" "viruses" for that matter.

The Virus Deniers are NOT claiming, "the germ believers never think about EMF and stress, diet etc, all they think about is the fake unicorn viruses!"

Believing in both terrain and germ theory simultaneously only causes more confusion and fear. One might think, "I've been poisoned from 60 different vaccines, I live in a place with lots of smog, I eat bad food, drink too much, stress too much, etc. Because my body, (terrain), is so unhealthy, I am now very susceptible to an imaginary "virus" or "pathogen" because my immune system is weak".

The VirusDenier's like myself disagree very strongly with this last statement. There's nothing to "catch" in the first place. This is the key to understanding. There is nothing to be afraid of. You can have the much needed close nurturing contact with any human family member who appears to be super contagious when in fact they are simply "deathly ill" from whatever terrain related issue they were afflicted with, be it a multitude of vaccines, antibiotics, chemicals, diet, etc. There's nothing to "catch" from them.

Your recent Substack post to Dr Michael Yeadon was very moving. I would also like to hear more from him about his change of stance. I can't imagine what you are going through as a loving and caring parent who is searching for understanding. You are wonderful for speaking your mind and supporting this open debate.

John's avatar

A good rail network can get you from A to B but that doesn't mean people who believe in railways don't believe flying saucers can also take you from A to B. Just because rail networks exist doesn't mean that aeroplanes and flying saucers don't. Alien abduction is real coz you can fly to New York in comfort and style.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
DR's avatar

That shows how two questions are mixed - do viruses exist and the disease that they (do or don't) cause.

And how to treat (or manage or prevent) a disease is a third question (even if it can be inked to the previous questions).

Faith's avatar

Exactly! Even if viruses had never been grown in cells and never been seen in electron microscopy, the diseases are real, and they spread AS IF by contageous pathogens.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Ryan Oreily's avatar

The moment you included “mind” you opened a completely new conversation, in which viruses may or may not have a roll. Maybe a calm mind IS the doing of certain viruses, allowing our bodies to not be susceptible to the harms of other viruses. I think it’s obvious that these packets of DNA exist. But the question is whether or not they cause the diseases we attribute to them…

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 6, 2022
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Mystic William's avatar

Are you saying there is no such thing as any sort of transmission at all? Virus or not? Bacterial or not? My experience of catching things tells me I catch nothing unless I’m run down. Colds and flus are certainly not easily transmissible, if they are at all. Many many times family members have been hacking and sneezing and I or my wife and I haven’t caught anything. I have had an alternative health practice for decades. I was for about 15 years full time at it seeing as many as 40 people a week. Many sick people. I NEVER caught anything! Why? However the Herpes things seems to be transmissible. OTOH....apparently 90+% of the population tests positive for having come into contact with Herpes. 1. We know the tests are meaningless. 2. If it is true 90+% have come into contact with it why don’t 90+% have it? It is possible skin to skin, open sore etc can transmit a pathogen. It might not be a virus though.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Gulag Inmate's avatar

What if you think of it as an "interaction" with a cell instead of an "infection". Say a protein is floating around in the air, when it comes in contact with your cells, your cells react to it. That thing wouldn't need "food" to create energy, it wouldn't need "energy" at all. And maybe humans have evolved with these things around us, and this is just how we deal with these proteins, maybe some benefit us, maybe some waste our energy on their reproduction. Just a thought.

Robert Cartwright's avatar

Perhaps, these proteins contain genetic information which is useful for the cell?

Nick's avatar

Similar to my understanding:

1. Viral particles float around

2. Passively enter the human body - say through the respiratory/alimentary system

3. Passively attach to receptors in the cells - put geometric locking aided by electrochemistry

4. The electrochemical environment at the site make the viral proteins to fold or transform enabling it to inject some particles into the cell - infection.

No need for self contained energy metabolism and use.

However it is news to me that virus particles have never been seen under a electron microscope! Is that for real?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Faith's avatar

Not all bacteria can move, only ones with flagella or cillia.

Virions don't need energy because they aren't alive. They are more like nano-size machines. Machines that have mechanical devices to latch onto structures on the surfaces of cells and, sort of like being "spring loaded", deploy their genetic material contents into the cell. The cell machinery then is fooled into treating the foreign genetic material like its own and sets about following the foreign coding to replicate new complete viral packages and spew them out.

Faith's avatar

Aren't sperm and ova also classed as "germinal cells"? Meaning that they begin the growth/life of something? As in "germinate"?

Bacca400's avatar

How do sperm move their tails if they have no mitochondria to generate energy?

Viruses do not "move" themselves to infect a cell. They float around, and when they bump into a cell, something about them burrows into the cell via molecular interaction, and then the virus reaches the nucleus where it releases its DNA to coopt the cellular machinery. There is no self-locomotion of a virus.

AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

Better analogy is in chemistry; chemical reactions require some activation energy, but this can be provided through thermal (brownian motion). Protein binding happens at temps above absolute zero and so molecules and macromolecules are constantly 'bumping' against each other.

The physics of docking that happens when spike protein bumps up to a cell is a science in itself.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6222344/

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 6, 2022
Comment deleted
AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

A magnet sticks to your refrigerator without an energy source.

Gulag Inmate's avatar

What does magnetism have to do with any of this? In fact there is an electric charge that is moving that causes magnets to stick (or repel) to your refrigerator. We do know electrons do exist :)

Faith's avatar

Why would chocolate-eating insects "isolate" the M&Ms instead just eat them/make them disappear?

Mystic William's avatar

If they make an insect that reproduces chocolate then that is worth a Nobel prize.

Faith's avatar

What do you think would be the "control" for a culture of viruses on cells? The same line of cells with no viral particles added? THAT is what happens EVERY TIME those cells are incubated/grown without the added virus!

Weihan Xing's avatar

Viruses DO exist. Those who deny their existence can put their knowledge and faith to the test by allowing themselves to be bitten by an animal known to be rabid. Case closed. And the coffin too.

Igor Chudov's avatar

do not attempt at home

do not attempt even if you got the "rabies vaccine"

Jo Waller's avatar

Hiya,

If you are bitten by a rabid dog and become ill- you don't pass the illnesses on to another person or animal, so it is not caused by an infectious or transmissible particle.

The observations are consistent with a neurotoxin produced by bacteria being present in the mouth of a malnourished and/or maltreated dog that are 'injected' into a person by the teeth of the dog.

All the symptoms of rabies are consistent with neurotoxic poisoning.

There is no evidence that a rabies virus exists, they have never found one, and rabies is not transmissible once bitten, but it would be very silly to allow myself to be bitten by a 'rabid' dog.

Jo

IntuitiveThinker's avatar

Lovely and logical. The same point I have made about herpes carriers who infect others that end up not being carriers. Hence herpes cannot be tranismisible by a non carrier.

Len Kinder's avatar

Yeah, that's a good point about Herpes. We're on a roll. Let's write a health encyclopedia.

Beckie Takacs's avatar

No - you are assuming all are transmitted through the air, and they are not. Rabies is not.

Jo Waller's avatar

there is no evidence that rabies is transmitted by a virus

Harmen's avatar

Well, it is not an airborne / airway infective virus. You have to be bitten first to get it.

If the person with rabies would bite another person, would the infection than be spread?

Stephanie B.'s avatar

Rabies is spread through saliva. Thus the "foaming at the mouth." So yes, humans can spread it potentially, but rabies is not airborne like a respiratory virus.

Jo Waller's avatar

So the 'virus' infects all your cells, multiplies inside, bursts out of the cells, escapes somehow back into the airways or GI tract and then leaves the host though it can only exist inside cells, and can only infect someone else by breaking their skin. I think we are so far down the virus rabbit hole we can't think straight. https://georgiedonny.substack.com/p/were-so-far-down-the-rabbit-hole

DrLatusDextro's avatar

Spot on, as Pasteur's own unethical 'experiments' to develop a rabies vaccine showed.

DR's avatar

What produces the neurotoxin?

Jo Waller's avatar

Bacteria. They seem to belong to the Vibrio, Aeromonas, Pseudomonas, Bacillus, Shewanella and Alteromonas genera

JO

Weihan Xing's avatar

It that's what you choose to believe, be my guest. Each to his/her own.

Petra Liverani's avatar

It's not a question of choice, it's a question of evidence. You need to look at the argument. Have you watched Sam Bailey's video? What have you read that denies rabies as an infectious disease has ever been properly identified?

Jo Waller's avatar

It's not what I choose to believe.

Show me the evidence that anything is caused by a virus

Len Kinder's avatar

I guess that's what Dr. Shelton was talking about years ago. Thanks for clarifying. Do you know where to find more info on the neurotoxins involved?

Jo Waller's avatar

They could be similar to tetrodotoxins produced by bacteria in puffer fish, these produce the exact same symptoms as rabies; hypersalivation, weakness, restlessness, paralysis, tremor, dysphasia (swallowing problems) and coma. It can also inhibit sodium channels and may lead to death.

I'm not sure there is any money in studying it, as everyone wants us to think there's a virus.

Jo

Mark's avatar

And don’t try to treat a rabid dog bite with St. John’s Wort and anti-oxidants....

Sorry, had to do it......delete if you must😎

Mystic William's avatar

That would be absurd. For that you need colloidal silver.

Mark's avatar

And the “Best in Class” award for 9/06/2022 goes to Mystic William....

Mark's avatar

I just choked on my drink🫡

Weihan Xing's avatar

LOL!!! Agreed.

John Raymond's avatar

Igor, you are a pisser, as funny as me.... almost.

KuhnKat's avatar

It would appear that rabies is a real condition. What is the evidence that it is what is termed a virus?

Igor Chudov's avatar

Good question. Great place to make a difference by making an insightful comment

Faith's avatar

The Rabies virus travels up nerves from the bite site to the salivary glands and the brain. Bigger things like bacteria can't do that.

And the farther away from the brain is the location of the bite, the longer it takes for central nervous system symptoms to develop. For instance, if you get bitten on the head or neck, you will become symptomatic much sooner than if you get bitten on the foot.

Weihan Xing's avatar

Exactly. But sadly, nothing we say or demonstrate can convince the cult of virus-deniers that these things are real. They've made up their minds and they're sticking to their guns. It's truly a cult-like thinking.

The Mallorn Tree's avatar

I believe this may be the kind of accusatory rhetoric that is unhelpful here. And I'm not on the "no virus" side. But folks are trying to make their point respectfully, why accuse them of being in a cult? I haven't seen cult-like arguments from them on this thread, anyway.

Petra Liverani's avatar

Which material that claims viruses have not been proven to exist have you consulted? You do need to immerse yourself in the argument and really come to terms with it before knee-jerking with "cult-like" thinking. Of course, the virus deniers can equally apply the term "cult-like" thinking to those who believe in viruses. Stay away from those sorts of epithets and stick to the argument.

Gulag Inmate's avatar

This must be the same person driving in their car with a mask on, yelling at people on the street to get vaccinated :) How about we just stay open minded and start from a position that just because other people don't agree with you, doesn't mean they are a "cult" or "deniers" of any kind. This is a tactic of the left and it usually doesn't end up well.

Faith's avatar

Interesting, but her very strong bias introduces the possibility that she is cherry-picking her "evidence". She is certainly "slanting" her conclusions. This does not constitute a scientific presentation on the subject. Very reminiscent of so much of the COVID propaganda. Is her assumption correct? How much evidence FOR the existence of a Rabies virus did she NOT present? She sounds like she is from Australia (or New Zealand), countries that she admits have almost no Rabies, which means there is a very high probability that she has never even encountered the disease. So why the interest? Because of its rairity it maks a good subject for promoting a "virus denier" position? Disease with the symptoms of Rabies has been observed in many different mammals. If it were something else, say a prion disease, would it be more specific in its hosts?

Are Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease in humans, Mad Cow disease in cattle, Scrappies in sheep and goats, Chronic Wasting Disease in the deer family, and the "prion"-configuration in the COVID shots' spikes all caused by the same mis-folded prion material or is it usually species-specific?

Lots of questions, few answers, especially since everyone seems to have an agenda to promote.

Diana's avatar

Your description of the journey of rabies “virus” sounds like the same pathology as snake or spider bite - it’s a toxin - not necessarily a “virus”. Actually the word VIRUS means “toxin” so maybe we’re all saying the same thing here! 😄

Faith's avatar

Snake and spider toxins start acting almost immediately. I've experienced both.

Rabies has to replicate, as pathogens do, before anything happens.

InfoHog's avatar

Also, in the 1990s, rabies among wild foxes in Germany (and probably they did that elsewhere in Europe, too) was severely reduced by regularly dumping oral vaccine bait thingies (no idea what it's called in English) the foxes pick up.

Faith's avatar

That's pretty wild!

Len Kinder's avatar

Faith, how does the virus travel through nerves?

Faith's avatar

Good question, but they do! The Chicken Pox virus that causes Shingles does it and migrates through an entire nerve "tree" to the skin, typically over a section of the chest or abdomen; plus other herpes viruses, and measels-type viruses like the one that causes Canine Distemper all hide out in nerves where the immune system can't get to them with macrophages to eat them. Bell's Palsey is from viruses getting inside the Facial nerve, one of the "cranial nerves" that come directly from the brain, and they cause swelling and pressure that cuts off nerve transmission to that side of the face, usually temporarily.

David Watson's avatar

We can measure the presence of organisms we call viruses. When it is present, the host gets sick. When it's absent, they don't.

Phil Welsh's avatar

Which came first, the virus or the sickness? Is a virus the cause of the sickness or is the presence of viral particles merely a symptom of feeling unwell? Are many, if not all, viruses simply the products of cellular detoxification (aka exosomes) which accumulate in extracellular fluids and make us feel bad? If so, what caused the systemic detox reaction to occur in the first place? The human genome seems filled with "viral" sequences, but what are they really? "Junk DNA"? Absurd! What are their actual functions, and why did Nature's evolutionary mechanisms and pressures ensure that they were accumulated and assiduously retained for succeeding generations?

These are questions virologists have done a miserable job of answering... recently, to the point of ignoring the questions entirely. The field of virology appears to me to be more cultish scientism at this point than pure scientific empiricism. As scientific disciplines go, virology is still in its infancy and will fail to mature into a respectable field of inquiry until it can be rescued from the vested monetary interests which have held it hostage for the past few decades.

I look forward to that day, as I'm an old, retired, marine microbiologist/medical researcher who still believes that one should gather facts and allow them to take you where they will. Only by allowing the light of truth to guide our path forward, can we ever hope to mutually build a brighter future for all of the lifeforms which share this magnificent little planet...

David Watson's avatar

Doesn't matter. All that matters is people are getting sick and governments are forcing therapies that not only don't work and are destructive. Therapies that do work, like ivermectin (an anviviral) are forbidden. Government is our worst pathogen, whether you call them administrators or rulers or tyrants, the result is the same -- bad outcomes for those who comply. Better to focus on issues that matter. Be ungovernable.

Greta Shames-Dawson, PhD's avatar

🍃🌺🍃 Beautifully stated, Phil Welsh!

Janet's avatar

“Vested monetary interests”. In a nutshell. I prefer to stay open minded about this. I found Cowans book and thoughts intriguing and it tickled a few thoughts concerning my faith and whom my faith rests on--The mystery of the human body we will never completely unravel. Likewise all life. We are electric beings.

DR's avatar

Do you have anything to support your theory? I would be interested to see it

Lawrence Mazzucchelli's avatar

You do understand that until CDC changed the definition of a vaccine and how they are made it always meant a "killed" or attenuated virus. Until you can collect virus particles you can't "kill" or attenuate them.

Jill Shank's avatar

I agree viruses exist however your statement does not account for complexities of the immune system. A virus can be present and not cause illness because the immune system neutralizes it. An example would be a family living together where the parents are symptomatic with covid but the kids are not. Clearly the kids have daily constant exposure to the virus yet not sick.

Weihan Xing's avatar

The rabies virus is one of the most lethal. Only a handful of people have ever survived a rabies infection without immediate treatment.

rich's avatar

do you not see the blatant contradiction in your statement? why havent any of the millions of household pets in America got Covid? easy... they dont watch TV....https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

Petra Liverani's avatar

So they tell us ... but has the scientific work been done to prove presence and absence and causing illness?

https://odysee.com/@drsambailey:c/What-About-Rabies:a

David Watson's avatar

And no "scientific work" has been done to prove parachutes work. But there's enough evidence to convince normal folks.

rich's avatar

bullshit...NO virus has ever been isolated...fake pictures of dead cells they call viruses dont count...https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

Matthew Hajzl's avatar

this only proves a technology for observing viruses is lacking... not that viruses to not exist.

not having proof of something is not proof something doesn't exist

David Watson's avatar

Those who rely on repeating things they read from anonymous internet posters, repeating them verbatim like religious liturgy, are at a survival disadvantage. Normal people realize the semantics don't matter, and focus on solutions that work. We have a choice of waiting for pathogens to be "isolated" or can figure out what works and leave the superstitions out of it. Antivirals work. Healthy immune systems work. Superstitions don't work.

Jo Waller's avatar

all your questions about the 'joker card' rabies answered here please watch https://odysee.com/@drsambailey:c/What-About-Rabies:a

Jo

Peter Nayland Kust's avatar

There is the vaccine developed by Louis Pasteur in the late 19th century.

https://www.jstor.org/stable/3560403?origin=crossref

There is phylogenetic analysis and reconstruction of rabies and other lyssaviruses providing a chronology for the evolution of the rabies virus

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5620125/

There are the electron microscopy studies of the rabies virus.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2106341/

rich's avatar

Pasteur is a known FRAUD...and using any "goverment" information to verify anything is ridiculous...just like Pasteur they are known liars....https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

Phil Welsh's avatar

Pasteur admitted late in life (some claim it was a deathbed confession) that his germ theory of disease wasn't incorrect, but it WAS incomplete. We now know that the TERRAIN is far more important than the microbe. Pathogens are opportunistic and will proliferate if conditions are suitable for doing so.

Focus on immune system health and it will keep you healthy. Address chronic nutritional deficiencies, maintain your internal chemistry in an alkaline state by eating more alkaline-forming foods and beverages, and employ natural, gentle, detoxing regimens on a routine basis. We live in an increasingly toxic world, so it's critically important that you perform intestinal cleanses/fasts and liver/gall bladder/kidney/lymphatic flushes. They're easy and inexpensive but require two things which seem to be in short supply in today's world... commitment and discipline.

Ouessante's avatar

Yep. 'Béchamp or Pasteur' by Ethel Hume.

Len Kinder's avatar

Peter, I think viruses exist, but I think there's much less known about them and about living cells than the establishment claims. Dr. Hillman said most means of observing cell & tissue contents etc damage them and therefore distort them. I'm trying to gather knowledge on this at https://ilki.substack.com/p/is-microbiology-real and https://ilki.substack.com/p/vax-questions-for-experts/comments and I hope to get expert input.

Peter Nayland Kust's avatar

The "experts" are infamous for overstating the extent of their knowledge. That much is certain.

Mark B's avatar

The rabies virus structure allows it to be genetically modified with a fluorescent protein. It can then be tracked and observed doing its virusy stuff. I did see something explaining this in plain English a while ago but can only find this at the moment. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC525074/

Weihan Xing's avatar

It is not caused by the Fed's increased interest rates or chocolate pudding, so there are two you can eliminate from your check list of possible pathogens.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022Edited
Comment deleted
Len Kinder's avatar

Dr. Hillman said electron microscopes destroy living cells. They apparently distort and damage the contents. So he said there are many misconceptions in microbiology. I'm writing about this at https://ilki.substack.com/p/is-microbiology-real

Mister Sir's avatar

Electron microscopy destroys the thing it's looking at AFTER the image is taken. You see the thing as it was just before you destroyed it by looking at it.

Think of pool: you start with balls arranged in a triangle and you shoot one ball at it. The one ball returns to you, evidencing that it hit something. But the thing it hit no longer exists; the triangle is scattered.

David Watson's avatar

Antibiotics do work, but against bacteria, not viruses.

John Raymond's avatar

I've been bitten by dogs... all have died. None from rabies.

Lightplague's avatar

Note to self: don't bite John Raymond

John Raymond's avatar

I told my brother... I don't want my wife spending 5 minutes in jail if she takes a butcher knife to me.

I freaking deserve it

Richard Seager's avatar

This has been done. Tried very hard to do something similar in 1919. Results - couldn't get it to transfer. Also I'm sure it's been done since.

Weihan Xing's avatar

Then clearly all the animals / humans who succumbed to rabies in the most painful manner were all delusional. It was just in their thinking.

Colin Thomson's avatar

I believe viruses exist and I also think they can cause disease but come on Rabbies is the fakest illness ever created.

Oh that dog is afraid of water! A well known symptom of Rabies! Ehh excuse me? How the hell does that happen?

Oh I'm sure we can trust Pasteur! He's not a fraud or anything.

Colin Thomson's avatar

I'm not letting any animal bite me lol whether they have rabies or not :p

Colin Thomson's avatar

Sorry for being so angry in my comment but I blame Pasteur for Raw Milk being illegal in my country so I really dislike him for a personal reason lol.

Phil Welsh's avatar

I was bitten by the bug of viral skepticism during the HIV=AIDS hoax. I'm still a carrier and doing everything possible to infect others. Fortunately, it's not a deadly condition, the symptoms are rather mild, and occasionally they are even rather pleasant and uplifting.

Faith's avatar

You might try getting on the 9/11 bandwagon . . . that can be even more fun! Try asking people how come that reporter announced that Building 7 had just collapsed when it was still clearly standing behind her!—a building that was never touched by the planes, and with a major CIA center with lots of incriminating records they wanted destroyed. Or how both towers started "pancaking" from the TOP many stories above the fire (as in planned demolition), when the bulk of the fuel would have flowed DOWNWARDS, and they did not buckle where the fires were. They SHOULD HAVE collapsed and just fallen over sideways from the point of damage if they were to fall on their own. There is NO WAY that every vertical support beam would have magically failed around the entire perimeter of each building at the exact same time like they did just from a fire in one part of each building!

One thing that COVID has taught us is TO QUESTION EVERYTHING, ESPECIALLY FROM THE GOVERNMENT!

Faith's avatar

I've been bitten by some strange critters! Even a mongoose! Lol! Haven't died yet!

Possum's avatar

I got bit by mossies, they dropped off dead.

Faith's avatar

They aren't "afraid of water" in any normal sense. The virus destroys the brain and in the process the animal loses control of its tongue and swallowing reflex and is unable to drink, and is very hyper-excitable and will behave very bizarrely because of all the damage, struggling and biting at things. This is why they are so dangerous to get anywhere near. Some countries still have high levels of rabies. Mexico does or did, at least until fairly recently. Rabies is no joke. Even cattle and horses catch it. Any mammal can catch it but not necesarrily transmit it Some small animals will die before the virus migrates to the salivery glands which would make them able to spread it. Pet ferrets cannot give you rabies from a bite because research has shown that they invariable die first. But bats, foxes, racoons, dogs, and yes, even horses, can give it to you if it is in their saliva. Rabies is not caused by some imaginary toxin!

Colin Thomson's avatar

If it has such a high IFR then how could it spread? Seems like Rabies is punishing its host by causing it to die so quickly.

It seems especially dumb for a virus to get its host to stop drinking. I mean what does it gain from that? Surely the Rabies virus that didn't do that would spread while the other strain die out.

I've never seen a pet nor an animal in the wild with rabies. You would think I would see 50, 100. I mean the rabid animal would be easy to spot.

I remember seeing a video of a man who couldn't drink as he was biten by a rabid dog. I dunno what to say it looked fake. Especially since the guy finally managed to take a sip before going into a panic.

I now fear of food can be due to a B1 ded. It makes sense that something similar is at play here.

Faith's avatar

They don't die quickly enough to break the chain of transmission. The virus gets into the salivary glands, and into the brain to trigger crazy biting behavior, so it spreads. Quite "brilliant", actually.

Alex's avatar

Wouldn't it be quite simple to take the neurons of an infected animal, implant them into healthy subjects and observe the development of rabies?

Faith's avatar

That's what they do by injecting brain tissue extract from suspected sick animals into test animals to definitively diagnose it.

Amy Sukwan's avatar

You went for the strongest argument right out of the gate! Point awarded to you there.

R!CKYRANTS's avatar

You can transfer a lot more than viruses, though.

Petra Liverani's avatar

But is the animal really known to be rabid?

https://odysee.com/@drsambailey:c/What-About-Rabies:a

I'd argue rather than viruses don't exist that viruses haven't been shown to exist which is not quite the same. It may well be that there are tiny pathogens causing illness but it seems they haven't been identified. What doctors such as Sam and Mark Bailey do is go through the scientific papers that allegedly show the isolation of a virus and its infectious nature and show that the authors of the papers have not followed the scientific method.

This is a video on the subject just published in the last couple of days.

https://odysee.com/@drsambailey:c/Viruses-Baileys-Cowan-Kaufman-Respond-To-Del-Bigtree:b

To argue for the existence of viruses it is necessary to look at the argument against their proven existence. Have you done that? Primary rule of critical thinking: aim to prove your hypothesis wrong and that means looking at all the argument that disagrees with yours and seeing if you can defend your belief against it.

Amy Sukwan's avatar

I just watched this video and I want to make some clarifications just as a point of argument. My understanding on viruses is that in theory they act as dead matter until they come into contact with the tissue or whatever. They can't be separated out because they won't do anything if they are. The baileys also argued that germs are inert. Taking this out to bacteria is going to far. My challenge there is to eat raw chicken that's been out in the hot sun for 7 days or the lick your fingers after cleaning your cat's litterbox with your bare hands...

Stan_R's avatar

Or Dengue fever, Amy

One million children injected in the Philippines who'll be vulnerable for Dengue for the rest of their lives.

Weihan Xing's avatar

No I haven't done that and frankly I have no intention to. The current virology model suffices fully for my lay understanding. I'm far more concerned about the propagation of lies promoting the death jabs. Also, the foundations of virology are not mine as I'm no biochemist, so in this case I'd prefer to accept the general consensus of millions of specialists who have continued to work on the basis of the reality of viruses. My own personal experience with viruses has offered me enough convincing evidence of their existence.

Richard's avatar

Please provide ONE study that shows where a virus has been isolated and purified. I’ll wait.

NickPNW's avatar

Viruses are cultivated in cell cultures and isolated all the time. There are photos taken of them using electron microscopes and their genomes have been mapped since the 1980’s. Experiments show animals infected with a virus can transmit it to other animals. Not everything is a conspiracy. Please, take off your tinfoil hat and put down the crack pipe.

Peter Nayland Kust's avatar

Well, there is the research of Dr. Li-Meng Yan, which argues laboratory construct for the virus.

https://zenodo.org/record/4028830#.YxXC_7TMK3D

Possum's avatar

Ask the Wuhan Institute of Virology, however, this name is probably conspiracy feary.

Richard's avatar

Yes because the Chinese don’t “LIE and STEAL”.

Gulag Inmate's avatar

We as humans like simple definitions of everything. Sure these proteins exist and are all around us, but maybe, it's just not as simple as you get it, you get sick because it's a virus. For example a lot of people think your brain is like a hard drive storing things like memories, but that is not at all the case, there is no storage, and no "memory" as we think of it (all we can compare to is a computer), yet for us to make sense of the world, we have to have the simple (low resolution) explanation or we'd all go nuts trying to live day to day. I bet proteins we call viruses are a lot more complicated and their interactions with our cells are a lot more complicated than we understand (even the "scientists"). I'd like to hear more of these "alternative" thoughts, they are very interesting to me at lease.

Weihan Xing's avatar

Virology / germ theory does not preclude terrain theory.

Gulag Inmate's avatar

Correct, and it can very much be a combination of both. However to the people that say it's "terrain theory" only (it seems this is not you) - I have a question - how to a lot of people all over the world have similar symptoms for what seems to be the same disease? Sounds like there has to be an external agent. I think the argument on here is what do you call that agent.

John's avatar

it took the allopaths hundreds of years to concede that scurvy was not a contagioous disease. Their logic was that they had seen 'it' spread around ships when actually all they had seen was a ship load of vitamin C deficient sailors.

Joe Major's avatar

What false rhetoric to try and argue a point.

Can you prove a virus exists?

Is Covid-19 a virus?

Where is the isolated evidence.

Covid-19 is an engineered biological weapon. Made by US and CCP lab Monkeys Baric and the bat lady.

Is it virus or bio weapons. The jabs make people sick.

Peter Nayland Kust's avatar

COVID-19 is defined as the disease caused by infection by the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41579-020-00459-7

Labeling it a biological weapon does not mean it's not a virus. Biological weapons are, by their very nature, infectious pathogens. Throughout history, infectious pathogens which pre-exist in nature have been used as weapons. Part of the rationale for bringing bioweapons into the Nunn-Lugar "threat reduction" fold was to put the bioweapons researchers of the former Soviet Union to "peaceful" work.

https://newsletter.allfactsmatter.us/p/when-is-bioweapons-research-not-bioweapons

While the overwhelming body of evidence indicates SARS-CoV-2 (CCPVirus) was developed within China's biolabs in Wuhan, that same evidence also establishes the virus' proximal origins from pre-existing bat coronaviruses.

https://newsletter.allfactsmatter.us/p/when-is-bioweapons-research-not-bioweapons

"Bioweapon" and "virus" are not mutually exclusive terms.

R!CKYRANTS's avatar

COVID-19 is a disease but it's debatable as to what causes it. The jabs do indeed make people sick.

Stephanie B.'s avatar

Also, this is the one time you really do need to get the vaccine. If you do not, you have like a 99% chance of dying.

Jon Grah's avatar

Who told you this? via CDC? WHO? Bill & Melinda Foundation?

Or how did you arrive at this conclusion?

Stephanie B.'s avatar

You know, not everything Western medicine does is an evil conspiracy, as much as I'm critical of it in general.

Faith's avatar

Very high-dose intavenious sodium ascorbate (vitamin C) will supposedly cure any viral infection, even rabies. Cures most Polio within 72 hours.

I certainly wouldn't choose to get bitten by a rabid aninal, though. Funny thing happened about four years ago— I heard a strange flapping noise when I was outside after dark— I turned my flashlight towards the sound and a bat flew straight up at me and bounced off my forehead!!! Bats aren't supposed to DO that, so I'm guessing it may have been rabid. Didn't break the skin, fortunately. VERY weird!!!

Stephanie B.'s avatar

So where are the studies showing IV C will cure acute rabies? And let's say it does work, great, but *where* will you get the treatment? Rabies is one of those things I wouldn't mess with. The people who die from it now are the ones who refuse the vaccine treatment, and the treatment needs to be administered quickly and on a schedule.

Len Kinder's avatar

Are there reliable studies on rabies vaccines? How do they work? Do they contain the virus?

AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

I got mononucleosis at 17. Mom put me on small doses of rose-hips vit-c every 1/2 hour with b-supplments, kept me under hot blankets constantly. Cleared symptoms within 10 days. C is a very interesting vitamin. Makes for a nice tart additive to ice tea and homemade sugar-free drinks, for sipping while work working.

Ajahn Dan Thiracitto's avatar

Check out the great interview with Dr. Pierre Kory, where he explains the great discovery of IV VitC as early treatment for Sepsis. Pretty cool. https://youtu.be/9J9fu3KOTR8

Faith's avatar

A study was done with mice that they injected diluted and filtered feces into their abdominal cavities to cause severe sepsis. Half the animals were injected with ascorbate intraperitoneally (in the abdomin) one hour later. They sacrificed the animals in a few days and every one without the vitamin C had their lungs massively full of fluid, inflammation, and were riddled with huge numbers of microclots. The animals given the vitamin C had perfect lungs except ONE mouse had ONE micro clot visible in the lung section under the microscope. That's pretty darn impressive, and probably quite relevant to COVID. I took a lot of vitamin C when I had the original (nasty!) strain of COVID in 2020, and my oxygen saturation never dropped at all, so I'm pretty sure my lungs stayed clear of clots, too!

Aimee's avatar

That man is a practical genius. Very creative, agile mind.

Phil Welsh's avatar

Congrats. You batted a 1000 that night...

Faith's avatar

Hey, I've made it this far . . .

Lol!

Cees's avatar

No you don't, and if you do or not, your chance of dying is always 100%.

Stephanie B.'s avatar

The comments here are quite alarming. I wrote up an article on the danger of rabies. https://wholistic.substack.com/p/rabies-get-vaccinated-or-prepare

Gulag Inmate's avatar

This is something completely different. You get that when you get bitten. This conversation is not about that at all.

Weihan Xing's avatar

Wonderful assessments, Stephanie! Your comments are spot-on, so I just subscribed to your substack. Excellent! Keep up the sane, enlightening work.

John Raymond's avatar

I don't know about viruses . But if I got bit by unknown dog id get rabies shot.

We vaccinate our dogs for rabies.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 6, 2022
Comment deleted
Len Kinder's avatar

le_berger, I don't see anything on rabies there at http://whale.to/

Len Kinder's avatar

Dr. Herbert Shelton used to say that rabies is a myth, that it occurs in the early spring when animals are coming out of hibernation and may be malnourished or starving.

Stephanie B.'s avatar

Ridiculous. It was not spring when this woman was attacked by a rabid fox a few weeks ago and the fox is clearly healthy enough to attack her relentlessly. https://www.pennlive.com/nation-world/2022/08/rabid-fox-attacks-woman-at-her-new-york-home-video.html

Len Kinder's avatar

A virus denier made a comment at https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/debate-viruses-do-not-exist-or-do/comment/8852250 suggesting that it's a neurotoxin, not a virus. Is that plausible? I see there are images of rabies viruses online. But I have a paper at https://ilki.substack.com/p/is-microbiology-real asking if Microbiology is sound, since Dr Harold Hillman showed good evidence that there are some serious errors, due to distortion of specimens via imaging techniques etc. I also have a post at https://ilki.substack.com/p/vax-questions-for-experts/comments trying to get experts to share their info explaining Covid & vaxes in considerable detail.

Len Kinder's avatar

PS, Shelton also said syphillis is a myth. He had a book called Syphillis, Werewolf of Medicine.

IntuitiveThinker's avatar

What we call rabies virus may actually be a venomous substance secreted by the immune system of a sick dog similar to the way some sick people secrete what we call herpes virus which become infectious to others who do not secrete the substance like herpes carriers

Stephanie B.'s avatar

"venomous substance secreted by the immune system of a sick dog"....you mean...a VIRUS.

John Raymond's avatar

I have no idea what either group is saying. Remj8of Baptism of desire argument

Richard's avatar

Wrong. Please point to One Study where the rabies virus has been isolated and purified.

Len Kinder's avatar

Point to a study where an electron was isolated and purified.

John Raymond's avatar

Always wanted to horsewhip author who had Old Yellow murdered. He wasn't showing any signs.

Piss on his grave

NickPNW's avatar

And after contracting rabies, they can attend a gay orgy and go for monkey pox with a touch of HIV.

Jo Waller's avatar

HIV is not the cause of AIDS and is not associated with homosexual intercourse.

AIDS is only correlated with receptive anal sex in either men or women. AIDs is a disease of oxidation; the anus is very thin and semen is highly oxidising.

Please see this demolition of the HIV/AIDS hypothesis https://georgiedonny.substack.com/p/the-importance-of-intellectual-freedom

Jo

CA's avatar

To me it’s a non-issue whether viruses exist or not. It’s like debating whether “climate change” is man-made or natural. Both “sides” ignore self and collective responsibility for getting consistent, long term, wholistic positive results. In the case of climate, that would mean minimizing pollution, reducing waste from all sources and changing manufacturing practices to cradle to cradle systems and creating more efficient, less toxic ways to produce needed goods and services or possibly rethink what we actually need and where we are simply doing things out of habit or from someone else’s profit motive without considering the total costs of our ”way of life”.

As regards “viruses”, “exosomes” or what have you, it doesn’t matter when you comprehend that optimal health is the best possible balance of toxin avoidance and removal and nutritional repletion. This includes not just diet, but one’s total environment, internal and external such as thoughts, emotions, trauma and its resolution, sunlight, hydration, mineral status, movement, exercise, breathing, air and water quality, frequency, rest, sleep, relaxation, meditative or contemplative habits, past and present relationships, etc. In other words, neither illness or health exist in a vacuum with singular causes and effects. Taking the time to figure this out for myself and continue to learn and apply has led to me not having even a sniffle in over thirty years and not requiring any medical attention in over forty. Kept doing what I know works throughout this prolonged period of upheaval and didn’t do any of the things so many insisted were necessary with the result that I am stronger and healthier than ever (and I was already off the high end of the charts for health and fitness) and no one I know who practiced all the “mandated things” can truly state that, if they are still even alive. I don’t believe in viruses or no viruses. I know what actually creates the results I seek. Somehow everyone wants to argue, but no one cares about demonstrable results. That’s all I care about. If your results are better than mine, I want to listen to you. If they are not, maybe you should listen to me…

Igor Chudov's avatar

I appreciate you taking an effort and posting your thoughts expressed in more than a few sentences!!!

Aimee's avatar

Yours is my favorite comment on the thread. 👍

Mystic William's avatar

Both are bringing about far reaching legislation. Both these must be fought tooth and nail. Your common sense approach is fine. I can’t argue with it. But that isn’t the situation we are in. If viruses have never been found in isolation, and this can be proved, then their whole medical edifice falls. We can take away a giant weapon they are currently using against us. Same with climate change. It isn’t true. That is abundantly clear now. But my skies are constantly being sprayed with a crosshatching of something. A neighbour’s nephew is in enviro studies at U Vic. He is thrilled they are seeding the skies to reflect light away from the earth. He says they are learning this in his science program. Yet, they aren’t telling us, the public, about it. It is ludicrous to monkey wrench with nature like this. It has never worked. Ever. So, it does matter how we treat these two issues. Because they are lying to bring about some sort of end.

feral lunch lady's avatar

It isn't known at this time. Let scientists keep working on it. The real question is, why is this question dividing people who are being genocided? Who started the silly food fight that keeps our attention off the people trying to kill us? My personal opinion: I have caught many colds, and often I know who I caught it from. It wasn't because I was unhealthy or had emotional problems, but because someone who had a cold was near me. Maybe terrain has an effect too, since I don't always catch colds from people who have them and are near me. But when I do, it doesn't seem random, it looks like causation. So I usually avoid people who are sneezing, I guess I do believe in viruses. But so what, the government is trying to kill me, and getting involved in a scientific feud is silly.

Igor Chudov's avatar

Your colds example is fantastic

John Sbrochi's avatar

Maybe it's both? You are exposed to a pathogen AND it's related to the environment. Nearly every time I get a cold, I can trace it to being either physically run down or emotionally distraught 1 or 2 weeks prior.

But yes - we should primarily focus on those who are trying to kill ( or make infertile) as many people as possible!

Barekicks's avatar

Sure, there's exposure and then there's susceptibility. So the outcome is an interplay of the two.

Vxi7's avatar

"It wasn't because I was unhealthy or had emotional problems, but because someone who had a cold was near me. "

How do you know you were healthy? Many people think they are healthy but are they really?

John's avatar

Sometimes I drive past a motorbike and need to go to the gas station to fill up. Othertimes I see a motorbike and still have plenty of fuel. In anycase it still seems like motorbikes drain my resources. The government is blaming motorbikes but I don't want to get involved in defending them and would rather accuse them of being to blame using anonymous anecdotal strories in the comments.

Wayne Costigan's avatar

Excellent book, THE MOTH IN THE IRON LUNG, makes a great case that nearly all cases of polio were NOT caused by the polio virus. Most were caused by environmental poison! And studies showed that only about one quarter of patients who were paralyzed tested positive for the polio virus. Turns out there are many other viruses that can paralyze. FDR showed symptoms inconsistent with polio and was most likely poisoned by summertime fruit that had been sprayed.

Richard Seager's avatar

Toxins, pollution, what you put in your own body are the other side of the coin. That these are causing the problems.

Just a question, if viruses existed would not vaccines work? In if fact there's no evidence of the second should we stop assuming the first?

I find the story of Pasteur and Beauchamp quite interesting. Seems like Fauci vs Kary Mullis.

JS's avatar

The chickenpox vaccine seems to have worked. Reasonable people may disagree over the net benefit, but it’s pretty clear that countries that have adopted that vaccine have had massive drops in cases, whereas kids in those without those vaccines all get infected. (I’ve lived in both).

Breezie's avatar

Chkn pox vax correlates w/ increases in shingles. "The universal chickenpox vaccination program is neither effective nor cost-effective and caused a dramatic rise in shingles: "From 2000 to 2001, reported HZ cases aged 20 years and older increased 18% in the AV-VASP (Fig. 1) [39] and this compares to the 22.5% annual increase reported in Massachusetts by Yih et al. from 1999 to 2003 [62]. A large 34% increase in HZ reports to AV-VASP was noted from 2001 to 2002 when an HMO (Kaiser) began reporting to the AV-VASP. This may have contributed to the high mean increase in HZ reports of approximately 28%/year among adults 20 years and older from 2000 to 2002 [39]. However, the AV-VASP reported a similar increase of 28% during 2006–2007 among adults aged 50 years and older as well as a larger 38% increase in HZ incidence among adults aged 50–59 years [63]. From 2000 to 2006, the incidence among those aged 10–19 years approximately doubled [63]." " https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264410X12007761?via%3Dihub

Richard Seager's avatar

Vaccines all came in on the tails of disease. And many believe chicken pox to be the outcome of a vaccine, I can't remember which one.

Jon Grah's avatar

How are you measuring the drop in cases?

How does the chickenpox vaccine (or any vaccine) stop wild infection? Does the manufacturer ever make that claim? Has that claim ever been attempted to be validated with some sort of double-blind study against a placebo (that was not another vaccine)?

And what exactly does a "case" of chickenpox mean? Is it like a "case" of covid-19?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Peter Nayland Kust's avatar

There is also speculation that what FDR actually contracted was Guillian-Barre rather than polio.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Edward Vidgen's avatar

For some reason the *like* button does not work with your comment (which means that I did try).

My view exactly.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
disfatbidge's avatar

Excellent book - more people need to learn about Forrest Maready

Gabriela's avatar

I just finished reading Turtles All The Way Down, and they devote a long section to polio specifically. The environmental poison theory makes so much sense. I was dumbfounded because my whole life, oh yes vaccine vaccine polio Salk vaccine! But maybe not...!

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022Edited
Comment deleted
Phil Welsh's avatar

The vaccination schedule for the young has swelled over the years almost as much as the DSM for mental disorders... and for precisely the same reason: the acquisition and retention of steady customers.

The etymology of words held important clues before the Rockefeller/Carnegie families declared war on natural health modalities with the issuance of their Flexner Report in 1910. My pre-PC 1828 edition of Noah Webster's "American Dictionary of the English Language" includes the following entries:

1) pharmaceutical - From the Greek "pharmacopaeia", to practice witchcraft or use medicine; poison or medicine.

2) witchcraft - The presence of witches; sorcery; enchantments; intercourse with the devil.

Yikes! Clearly, the worst plagues circulating in today's world are BigPharma's and BigBiotech's products, folks! Our telescreens are saturated with urgent messages to "take your medicine", "ask your doctor about ___", "get your jabs!", etc. etc.

Caveat emptor...

JustANobody's avatar

Love this comment. It's All true!

Powerful Secret Knowledge's avatar

Viruses don't exist (by Dr Thomas Cowan and others, allegedly via Rudolf Steiner) - Viral sickness is a cyclical detox that can be triggered by seasons in conjunction with cellular necessity. Proximity to a tribesman in detox signals a safe time for the rest of the tribe to also detox. Also the things we call viruses are a detox assistant machine created by our cells.

The irony of the Steiner theory is that detox is transmissible like a virus, almost like the Greek miasma (contagious darkness of the soul). The detox machine theory also invokes behavior comparable to a virus. Even the notion of a "DNA upgrade" for detoxing that is sharable but kills some people begs the question of quarantine.

Do viruses exist? Is the wrong question perhaps because both theories "agree" on some parts. The important part is why are viruses inconsequential for some and not others? Are viruses a crucial part of the organism or something to be eliminated? And are lab made viruses breaking the natural paradigm?

OldSysEng's avatar

How does "proximity detox" signal, and thus spread? I'm quite confused by this concept.

Spadesman's avatar

Through "exosomes" which is one theory I read about. Basically they can't explain how the same symptoms spread from person to person, but it is definitely "NOT" a virus...

Just a Clinician's avatar

Those are some very good questions.

R!CKYRANTS's avatar

I don't think the question is whether or not viruses exist, but whether or not they are contagions. People have clearly identified particles under microscopes that were called virions.

Banta's avatar

Spot on, and this is a far more difficult issue to adjudicate than either side of the issue may admit. Let us not forget Koch’s first postulate that has been all but abandoned with Typhoid Mary and the existence of the asymptotic carrier, “the microorganism must be found in abundance in all organisms suffering from the disease, but should not be found in healthy organisms.”

This does not undo viral theory on its own but reminds us that we are outside the realm of pure cause and effect relationships. Health is a complicated matter, of which I think we greatly underplay the importance of mindset (look no further than the placebo effect), and we are constantly looking at correlations at best. This is to say nothing of the alleged controversial discoveries of folks like Bechamp and Rife, which recent history should give us all pause to summarily dismiss them as cranks.

I personally think there is room for viruses being both a reaction of the immune system and a toxifying agent that can be spread. And potentially a non-concern if your faith, so to speak, is high enough. In order to study physical phenomena, we must discount the role of consciousness impacting what we are observing. This is a rational approach, but rationalism and objectivity are ultimately only a philosophy and there are no guarantees that reality (whatever that is) has to play by those rules.

Sorry if this went a bit too “woo” but I think it’s hard to avoid if we want to be completely honest on what we think we know.

Colin Thomson's avatar

Remember, there was a time when the experts of the time were sure that Scurvy and Pellegra were caused by a virus or something contagious. People on the same ship get those diseases so they must spread it to one another! B12 def caused by virus! Iron def? Virus! Beriberi disease?! Must be a virus

Peter Nayland Kust's avatar

The contagious/infectious nature of viruses predates their visualization under electron microscopy.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7150144/

The first viruses to be isolated were confirmed as contagions by the isolation tests themselves.

R!CKYRANTS's avatar

That one leads with smallpox, so I'm going to assume it has some wrong information.

Edward Vidgen's avatar

Viruses don't exist on the flat Earth.

It is our misfortune that we are somewhere else.

Igor Chudov's avatar

I agree that we are not on flat Earth. But do viruses exist on the round Earth? If so, what is the evidence in support of that?

Greg C's avatar

The point is, he is calling anyone who does not BELIEVE in Viruses a Flat Earther. I'm out of here.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Greg C's avatar

Great answer, and I saw the length you went to, to explain your perspective on the F.E. subject. But conversing with him is pointless. He is simply a covertly hostile, smug, arrogant, troll. I don't feed trolls.

Edward Vidgen's avatar

What's in a name? That which we call a virus / By any other name would make us as sick

Jo Waller's avatar

Hiya,

We can categorically say there is no evidence that viruses exist or that they cause disease (which is hard if they don't exist!)

In order to observe tiny particles, such as viruses, a sample from a patient with the disease is placed in a sucrose density gradient and centrifugation is performed. Viruses are thought to have a density of around 1.16g/cm3 so they should gather in this band.

Viruses could not be visualised in this band using samples from Covid patients. So how did they know that what couldn’t be seen was causing the disease?

please see my short run down of the evidence

https://georgiedonny.substack.com/p/seeing-is-believing

Jo

Edward Vidgen's avatar

You may well be right in regards to *COVID* issue, which is dodgy-sketchy to say the least.

But I thought this discussion was more general than that.

In fact, the specific notion that viruses collect in the 1.16g/cm3 density band would be most curious if viruses don't exist as such—why 1.16, why not 0.03 or 501 for that matter since ANY random number would be equally (dis)qualified?

Otherwise I may as well claim that angel dust can be caught in 3.88g/cm3 region and demand a Nobel (in presumably new category).

Jo Waller's avatar

Ps. Thank you so much for reading!

I've summarised the main points about how 'HIV' cannot be the cause of Aids here, if you don't want to read the superb but long article by the Perth Group https://georgiedonny.substack.com/p/the-importance-of-intellectual-freedom

Cheers,

Jo

Jo Waller's avatar

Indeed.

The viruses I am referring to are the ones of virologists own definition of being proteinaceous coated particles, sometimes with characteristic 'fringes', with RNA or DNA inside them, and with similar sizes and shapes. There have different types that they refer to, for example HIV is claimed to be type C shape, however these are not lentiviruses, which are the ones with the characteristics that HIV is meant to have. So even by their own definitions they can't find them or agree what they should look like.

For a thorough explanation of this please see http://www.theperthgroup.com/HIV/TPGVirusLikeNoOther.pdf

Edward Vidgen's avatar

Further on I posted example of a virus so big that anyone can see it through a beginner's microscope, bigger than most bacteria and answering all the requirements to qualify as a virus (retrovirus, I believe). If someone who struts his open-mindedness refuses to engage in debate and prefers ad-hominem/ad nauseam, so be it, no skin off my nose.

Jo Waller's avatar

Giant 'viruses' in the sea exist, so do bacteriaphage. They cannot be demonstrated to be 'viruses' ie pathogenic transmissible, please show the evidence if you have it. They seem to be more like spores, produced under stress containing genetic material of the organism to ensure survival.

How do you know they retroviruses ? if it's because they contain reverse transcriptase, this has been shown to be present in nearly all cells.

Jo

Edward Vidgen's avatar

Look, g&d, first of all, I am not a life scientist and don't have the tools to enter into a technical discussion on any biological topic.

Secondly, the big guy I mentioned attacks amoebas, enters their cell nucleus, replicates rapidly until the host explodes and hundreds of replicas of the 'virus' (since you put it under quotes, I follow suit given my limited understanding) and that is a good enough definition of 'virus' for my money. In other words, the 'virus' is not viable as a self-replicating organism outside the host's cellular machinery.

I will leave it at that, and try to maintain my physiological health by avoiding such beasts and y mental health by not pursuing the subject down the rabbit holes reserved for specialist rabbits.

Ajahn Dan Thiracitto's avatar

I have to admit, that I would even delete this kind of condescending commentary. We should not engage in ridicule. It is not productive especially for this honest invitation for both sides to discuss their arguments.

disfatbidge's avatar

Except for the fact that there is a very large movement of those who are self proclaimed ‘Flat Earthers’. They have their own evidence to prove it.

freelearner's avatar

I think flat earthers, the 9/11 hologram plane people, and the "nobody was involved in JFK except the mob" are essentially CIA / Cass Sunstein astroturf-type "conspiracy theories" that are used to silence anyone with far more legitimate, evidence based questions and skepticism. If you want people to distrust criticism of covid-19 vaccines, claim they make you magnetic, makes the whole community look nuts, right? Whether the "germ theory isn't real" people fit into this or not I do not know. Clearly PCR results have been massively misinterpreted.

Vxi7's avatar

Absolutely this. And I say this to everyone since years. These far fetched conspiracy theories are sure to be spread by agencies to make everyone look like a loony if they come up with valid points.

rich's avatar

watch and learn why the virus theory is a hoax...https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Faith's avatar

But if they get in a ship and sail off the edge of the Earth, they can’t come back to certify that it isn't round! And BTW, what keeps all the ocean water from running off the egde, too?

Hey, people I have FLOWN all the way around the Earth. Believe me, IT IS ROUND!

AlreadyLoggedin2Sbstack's avatar

But where's the EVIDENCE? The pilot just told you it was around the earth.

Edward Vidgen's avatar

Your are entirely correct. Maybe viruses do exist on flat Earth and I am just guessing.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
K. Vleerick's avatar

Who knows what to believe anymore. It is strange that the United Nations, the World Health Organization, the International Civil Aviation Organization, the International Maritime Organization, and the Young Global Leaders Network all use a Flat Earth map in their logo.

Nancy's avatar

🤣

Banta's avatar

Visible geometric horizons don’t exist on globe earth either, but that’s beyond the scope of today’s discussion.

Igor Chudov's avatar

Actually they do, go to a top of a mountain or a big hill near the ocean.

I experienced that when I was perhaps 10 and I was very impressed to see that the earth is round.

Banta's avatar

If that’s good enough for you, that’s fine by me. But there’s a lot more related to optics involved with creating a horizon than one may initially think. Most people involved in the shape of the earth discussion, even those who ardently back the globe, concede that we do not see the actual geometric horizon basically ever, because there is refraction and other elements at play. And this has to be the case for the globe model because the distance to the geometric horizon is 1.22 times the square root of the observer’s height in feet and there are a plethora of observations that exceed this by 10x or greater.

A wog at the Tropics's avatar

No, you couldn't see it, unless you were on top of the Everest. And even NASA now admits you need to as high as 65,000 ft to see it, not 35,000.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19037349/

Greg C's avatar

That, sir, is a veiled attack on those who do not fall for the Virology Hoax. I thought he asked us to not use personal attacks.

Edward Vidgen's avatar

A few remarks are warranted here:

• Repurposing your logic means that your reply is a veiled attack on those who believe that the Earth is flat (and in fact I know such a person and have all kinds of respect for him),

• How would you classify the Ebola patients—victims of autosuggestion and/or superstition?

• All those dozens of Pentagon-funded biological weapon labs surrounding Russia, collecting DNA samples of (take note) <b>strictly Russian ethnics—NOT Ukrainian</b> (documents captured by Russian forces in Mariupol and elsewhere)—what was their purpose if not virological ... or are they that daft?

• I have also referenced actual, physical photos of (big) viruses, visible under a dime store microscope—feel free to relabel it as mystery meat, I am slow to take offense,

• On the final note, my apologies if your feelings are hurt, such was not my intention.

Greg C's avatar

See my middle finger? Kindly repurpose that. I don't need to be Red Herringed by your ilk.

If that hurt your feelings, it was my intention.

Edward Vidgen's avatar

I don't see your middle finger, so I will leave it to you for endless viewing and admiration.

Don't be discouraged easily by fatigue, just lean your nose onto it while you gather your strength.

My feelings are nowhere near as hyper-touchy-feely as yours, maybe will reach that point when-if I hit the male menopause but I do get bored by people with nothing but vitriol to contribute—dime a dozen in any crowd.

Keep up screeching and shaking the branches, I will not waste a second more checking your precious input.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 5, 2022
Comment deleted
Ajahn Dan Thiracitto's avatar

I fully agree here. And on top of it, how can we observe other spherical objects like planets and moons in the sky, but dismiss the same possibility for our habitat?

John Raymond's avatar

Changed my mind from do not know.... to more hopelessly confused than before.

Analogous to fierce sedevacantist argument... how will we get a true pope: very imperfect conclave? Traitor apostate false cardinals miraculously converting to Catholic faith? Direct intervention of God.

All of it... I am very limited, but Gates with a needle 🪡 in his hand grinning AIN'T A COMFORTING LOOK.

Verwayne Greenhoe's avatar

I have a BS in Biology from a major Big Ten college and I have seen viruses under a microscope. Not your average $300 microscope, but I have seen them move and some "vibrate." They are extremely small, which why masks were quite ineffective. Viruses could march fifty wide through a mask and never touch a fiber of the mask.

I'm 69 and my wife is 68. She was an OB RN for 44 years and I was a paramedic for 12 years and an Emergency Room RN for 27 years.

I have seen active bacteria under a microscope and active viruses under a special microscopes.

Thank you for the chance to weigh in here.

Igor Chudov's avatar

Thank you for your great comment

Chymist's avatar

That "vibration" is called Brownian Motion. Small particles are colliding with other molecules.

Bono's Mullet's avatar

What kind of "special microscope" enabled you to view "viruses" moving and vibrating? To my knowledge, what are termed viruses are only visible under an electron microscope, for which the process of preparation necessarily means that what is viewed is not even close to its natural state, and in fact it must be dead.

123abceng's avatar

Thanks God, we have a person who have seen viruses by naked eye! Something wrong happened with microscopes in the 21 century... I would like to know what a microscope is a source of truth for Dr. Sam Bailey ))))) Anyway, Sr, you are the best here!

Dell's avatar

I have heard both sides of the argument. Both have points. I have come to the conclusion that they DO exist. I think the immune system is real and if it is depleted it cannot keep viruses at bay.

Ajahn Dan Thiracitto's avatar

Same for me, listened to both, but finally expierencal and observational knowledge made me also decide for virus exists.

But....before Plandemic I laughed and ridiculed friends of mine who went down the flat earth rabbit hole, but COVIDtimes humbled me, and I try to never again make condescending prejudicial judgements. I sat down and honestly tried to listen to their arguments. They are definitely not all stupid, they sometimes have actually interesting points, which i have no studied answer to. They could not convince me, but at least they dive in and research and questions things.

Being ridiculed and laughed at as a stupid antivaxxer (who has all essential shots, plus last year's rabies shot) made me much more empathic to other people's opinions.

Igor Chudov's avatar

100% on board with your last paragraph!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

rich's avatar

by that statement I can assume you've never done real research on vaccines...start here...please watch before replying then we can discuss...thanks...https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

Ajahn Dan Thiracitto's avatar

I became definitely more suspicious after the COVID scam, and will probably never take any new untested vaccine again. But not fully convinced that all vaccines have no benefit.

rich's avatar

so you got all the ESSENTIAL shots?...do you even know all the toxic shit they put in vaccines? vaccines are just a big pharma money grabbing scam that are more harmful than any so called virus you have....this is obvious to anyone whos done real research on the vaccine hoax....https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

ChrisRd's avatar

How does the immune system get depleted? By accumulating toxins and/or deficiencies, right? That might actually explain the development of symptoms better than anything else...

JS's avatar

I don't think this alone can be an explanation, although it surely is a factor. How can toxins/deficiencies explain the existence of various childhood diseases that only get caught once and then confer lifelong immunity?

ChrisRd's avatar

Toxins can lead to immunity, it's not just a virus thing. You can build immunity to cyanide--definitely not a virus.

Some adults develop symptoms of those developmental diseases too, and it's possible--though rare--to experience them more than once. Also, isn't shingles the adult version of chicken pox for people with depleted immune systems?

JS's avatar

But how can a toxin spread from one person to another? If I ingest cyanide, it's not going to produce a chain of identical symptoms in the people around me and their contacts. My observation of chickenpox is that there is a clear temporal and local correlation in the chain of infection.

I realize that there are rare reinfection cases, but nothing in nature is truly 100% (not even biological sex, which is about as binary as it gets). I can't spend all my time on the various caveats and corner cases. If something is true 95%+ of the time, I think we can both agree that it's the norm, and then just keep in the back of our minds that things get fuzzy at the extreme margins.

As regards shingles, the official hypothesis is this: the chickenpox virus lies latent in the nerve system and can end up getting reactivated through a combination of waning immunity to that specific virus, plus a general weakened immune system. This produces the sickness known as shingles. But shingles as a disease is not contagious (i.e. we don't see shingles outbreaks following a typical infection pattern), because it is dependent on the person having both prior immunity AND a currently weakened immune system. However, exposure to a person with shingles can actually give you chickenpox if you're not already immune. For a person who has already had chickenpox, being around others who currently have it can give the immune system a natural "booster". This is why there has been a marked increase in the number of incidences of shingles cases since the chickenpox vaccine became common, and older folks don't get to be around those with chickenpox. But most children and young people in America today get neither chickenpox nor shingles, due to the vaccines.

This seems like a very logical and internally consistent explanation to me. If I saw a different hypothesis that explained it better, I would certainly consider it, but so far I haven't seen anything.

KatO's avatar

I believe viruses do exist because I've seen a variety of sicknesses start with one family member then spread through the rest of us!!! Chicken pox parties would be a good example as well seems like those existed 🙃

OldSysEng's avatar

OK, but does contagion equate to virus-exists? Admittedly something is contagious, but what?

KatO's avatar

Well, virus is just a name that was given to a pathogen that causes illness and is contagious. So based on the definition of the word I think yes it is fair to say its a virus. You could say its a contagious pathogen instead but again virus is just a word with a definition and there are many things we name but don't fully understand

Conway Judge's avatar

UNSURE but lean towards VIRUSES existing. Here is why.

I worked as a medic in an army camp (Actually quite a few over the years) but this one in particular was the first port of call for the recruits and officer cadets in training. So we had large numbers of young men coming in and out all year round. Usually in the hundreds at a time.

Anyway, can you imagine what happens when you get hundreds of young men and women and put them together in a few closely connected barracks?

You get outbreaks. And I saw quite a number of these over the years.

I saw scabies outbreaks. Which is a parasite not a virus

I saw noravirus/gastro outbreaks. Quite frequently. Who knows could be bacteria or a toxin and not a virus. We tested for bacterial infections but those routinely came back negative.

I also saw what was allegedly swine flu too going back to 2008/9ish

All outbreaks were primarily dealt to with quarantine and decontamination. Tis the army way.

Scabies for example. Was to remove the obviously infected and put them in another smaller barracks until they didn't show symptoms (quarantine). Prophylactically treated the rest of the barracks with permethrin. Then strip and decontaminate the barracks and all clothing and linen was hot washed.

Norovirus was similar. Those sick were put in the small ward at the treatment center and were treated as needed, most of them just needed to rest and be warm for a couple of days. A couple needed IV saline and other treatments. The barracks and toilets/ablutions were thoroughly decontaminated. No other treatment beyond corrective retraining in field hygiene practices for all the others. Lucky them.

The swine flu outbreak we had actually occured in a senior NCO course which was smaller (50ish) and had older more experienced soldiers. They were housed/quarantined in their own barracks separate from those who were not sick (quarantine) and as a medic I delivered their meals and took periodic observations and handed out basic medicines as needed. Most were fine. A couple had nasty fevers. All recovered.

All scenarios eventually ended. Removing the sick individuals from the majority into quarantine worked. It didn't continue or spread throughout the rest of the camp. If this is not viral contagion... How? What else made this work?

Also the similarity in the environmental conditions and food eaten. I just don't see how terrain theory alone explains this

Faith's avatar

NO "toxins" behave the same way viral outbreaks do!!!

Conway Judge's avatar

Toxins from where? Why some and not all? Why the appearance of contagion?

ChrisRd's avatar

Were the diagnoses made based on symptoms or tests?

Conway Judge's avatar

Scabies: Can see them/tracking. No test needed.

Norovirus: Assumed. Fecal samples were collected and tested for bacterial infections and routinely came back negative. No viral test from my knowledge. All symptomatic.

Swine flu: Assumed too I think. So based on symptoms. This I had little to do with beyond carrying out orders which came from doctors and officers up the line. I was a lowly private at the time.

ChrisRd's avatar

Hmm. I was hoping you'd say that ;)

Did anyone notice that the young women's menstrual cycles also started syncing as a result of being in "closely connected barracks"? I'd argue it's pretty much the same process, yet no one's blaming it on a virus. Those symptoms can develop without being "caught" and individual isolation can make them stop too...

Conway Judge's avatar

Interesting. So you think this is a bio-syncronizing phenomena?

Other than the scabies. That's pretty apparent a little mite/parasite

Faith's avatar

I believe menstrual symptoms are supposed to sync up because of pheromones . . . heard somebody talking about it recently in an online "Summit".

nikolai's avatar

Viruses definitely do exist. This leads to a grave concern of mine throughout the whole pandemic: not only those who deny the existence of covid, but virii entirely. I'm not sure where the idea began that no one had isolated the covid virus, but it began somewhere and many seemed to latch onto it for some reason, in what appeared to me to be a rationalization towards it being engineered by humans.. But then if its engineered and not a virus, what is it? Just a toxin? That catch all pseodoscience phrase in league with holistic mumbo jumbo...

R!CKYRANTS's avatar

Maybe it was because Fauci said the virus was isolated in China and that's what they used to make the Moderna vaccine in two days. A year later, China said they never isolated the virus. Where's the proof the virus was *properly* isolated and by WHOM? People are still waiting.

this little authoritarian's avatar

JJ Couey of gigaohmbiological makes a good case that sars cov-2 was released (deliberately/accidenatlly) on a background of a whole (and constantly circulating) swarm of such viruses. Until sars, coronoviruses had been notoriously difficult to culture (hence why there was little tinkering with coronaviruses until sars). There was also already a background of cross-immunity from other c-viruses but this lineage just has a particularly nasty spike. PCR testing has complicated things because originally they were tracking the spike but now they are not anymore. Given c-viruses recombine readily with each other it's hard to say what is or is not happening. Coronaviruses such as OC43 kill people regularly (mostly elderly) every year but since they do not culture them they are classified as PLI (pneumonia like illness).

Anyway, he makes a very good case for the existence of viruses but the covid situation is mighty murky, complex and full of shenanigans which sets up the no-virus position quite well, although he disputes it's biological foundation.

rich's avatar

if "viruses: actually existed mankind would have gone extinct long ago...https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

this little authoritarian's avatar

I'm not convinced by that video but honestly it doesn't bother me that others believe such things because as long as I'm not enforcing medical interventions upon others (and vice versa) then it's kind of moot.

People can believe whatever they want. Have at it. I will act accordingly.

Bono's Mullet's avatar

Did you actually watch all 2+ hours? If so, what questions do you still have that need further clarification?

If not... figures.

rich's avatar

its because of the "virus" myth that they are able to push their plandemics...lockdowns...and mandated vaccines....that is why you should give a shit...the plandemics will continue forever...see monkey pox and the resurgence of the "polio" hoax as two recent examples...the documentary provides all the stubborn FACTS exposing the scam...so yeah I will have at it and yes you should act accordingly...start by getting another booster

rich's avatar

viruses definitely do exist? why because you were told they do?...holistic mumbo jumbo? is that like vaccine mumbo jumbo pseudoscience? I take it you got the jab to protect you from the deadly virus that mysteriously doesnt kill any of the millions of household pets in America.....explain that shit....https://www.bitchute.com/video/rHmg8EY3cXPD/

MrSeahorse's avatar

Just have a question, if viruses don’t exist, what causes the communicable disease/infection? What is the “thing” that makes people sick with the same symptoms?

Just a Clinician's avatar

And why the vast diversity of diseases and manifestations? If it's just "toxins", why does it manifest with such varying symptomatology?

Bono's Mullet's avatar

If they manifest with such varied symptoms, then wouldn't that be a better argument against the model of "one pathogen - one disease - one cure"?

The way that even Convid was defined under a huge umbrella of syndromes alone proved to me that it couldn't be caused by a virus that behaves in a consistent manner, and that it actually doesn't exist. Rather, it was just flu symptoms re-branded, with an added measure of media and government hype like "covid toe".

OldSysEng's avatar

Covid toe may sound silly but I actually have it. It is most likely related to micro-clots that have no where else to go, having reached the "end of the line" so to speak.

My experience with the thing called covid is that it is UNLIKE any flu or other illness I have ever had in my 7 decades. More severe, more odd symptoms. And I'm not ... you know what.

Just a Clinician's avatar

Viruses, as a whole, are genetically distinct, and manifest as different diseases. Measles is not herpes is not hepatitis is not chickenpox is not mumps is not rabies. The patterns in which they erupt also argue against weak terrain as the only answer.

It gets into some deep science, but all the varied manifestations of COVID are one or another pathway caused by spike proteins, which has been called the "swiss army knife of death". https://wmcresearch.substack.com/p/coded-to-kill-a-short-range-mid-range

John's avatar

If santa doesn't exist how come santa put presents under the xmas tree? It is a circular argument where the hypothesis is never questioned. Santa exists and that is it. You would have to first prove there was a "communicable disease/ infection" before you could ask how come santa put presents under the tree. Did you consider that maybe it was uncle Joe that put the gifts there?